ODAC News

 

Sunday 01 April

 

The Oil Depletion Analysis Centre

 

 

1/   Turning Off the Taps - Is Russia About To Cap Its Oil Production?        (Russia Profile, Fri 30 Mar)

2/   Iran: We will know soon…     (Global Public Media [Richard Heinberg], Tue 27 Apr)

3/   Labour and Skills Crisis Could Stall Oil and Gas Investment Boom       (Booz Allen Hamilton, 24 Aug 2006)

4/   World Oil Production Close To Peak  (Science Daily, Fri 30 Mar)

5/   Shell Oil exec urges policy change    (Montgomery Advertiser, Fri 16 Mar)

6/   New Book:  The Last Oil Shock: A Survival Guide to the Imminent Extinction of Petroleum Man

7/   Branch of US Government Releases Report On Peak Oil         (ODAC Bulletin Board, Sat 31 Mar)

 

Back issues of ODAC News: click here

 

**********************************************************************************************************

 

1/         Turning Off the Taps - Is Russia About To Cap Its Oil Production?         (Russia Profile, Fri 30 Mar)

 

http://www.russiaprofile.org/page.php?pageid=Business&articleid=a1175260843

 

Comment:    ODAC discusses the likely consequences of Russia/Putin capping Russian oil production.

 

Article:    Russia is currently the largest oil producer in the world, and second only to Saudi Arabia in terms of oil exports. In terms of future growth, in its Medium-term Oil Market Report published in February 2007, the International Energy Agency (IEA) forecasts Russian oil production to increase over the period 2006-2011 by 1.1 million barrels per day (Mb/d). Russia’s growing production will play an important role in future global supplies of oil.

 

There are however two issues that raise doubts regarding Russia’s abilities to increase its’ oil exports. First, from February 2006 to February 2007, Russian oil production increased by over 400,000 barrels per day (b/d), whereas exports remained flat. That is to say, Russia did an exemplary job of raising its oil production, but consumed all the extra oil itself. This is not surprising – growth in Russian car production and sales through 2006 was phenomenal, and is forecast to remain so until at least 2010. The long-term implications of this are that even if Russia maintains its oil production growth as forecast by the IEA – estimates thought to be optimistic by some analysts – Russian oil exports will still continue to drop.

 

Secondly, President Vladimir Putin is thinking of capping Russian oil production. In this month’s issue of Petroleum Review, Chris Skrebowski reviews the London-based Energy Institute’s International Petroleum Week which was held in February:

 

... So Russia may be about to cap its oil production just when the global community is looking for it to produce more oil. Of course, that is the global community’s problem, not Russia’s. The problem goes further than Russia capping its oil production though. The country may be setting a precedent. One of the biggest conundrums within the so-called Peak Oil community is why every oil producing country, and there are about 100 of them, pumps its oil as fast as it can when it is a finite resource, and is inevitably going to become scarce one day. Oil production has already peaked and is now in decline in over 60 countries. There are a few countries that produce a lot of oil relative to the size of their population – Norway and Kuwait for example – and where a high standard of living could be maintained by producing much less oil. Indeed, Kuwaiti citizens pay no income tax and the national budget had a surplus of 40 percent in 2006. It is somewhat bizarre therefore that Kuwait is planning to increase its oil production from about 2.5 Mb/d now to about 4 Mb/d by 2020.  

 

In summary, if and when Russia caps its oil production, it will send alarm signals worldwide for two reasons. As Russian oil consumption is currently growing, oil exports will correspondingly fall at a similar rate. Secondly, capping production may set an example that others will want to follow, especially if global oil production is seen to be peaking any time between now and 2015.

 

**********************************************************************************************************

 

2/         Iran: We will know soon…                       (Global Public Media [Richard Heinberg], Tue 27 Apr)

 

http://globalpublicmedia.com/richard_heinbergs_museletter_180_iran_we_will_know_soon

 

Comment:    Richard turns his attention to what some think is the imminent attack on Iran by the USA/Israel.

 

Article:    For the past two years or so informed commentators (including Seymour Hersh and Scott Ritter, among others) have been predicting a US air attack on Iran. MuseLetter for March 2005, titled “Onward to Iran,” summarized relevant information available at that time. In recent months concern over America’s intentions has grown even more intense, to the point that it has become the fulcrum of nearly every discussion about the future of world affairs.

 

As many have pointed out, an attack could have cataclysmic implications for the region, for the world economy, and not least for the oil import-dependent and nearly bankrupt US. Recently Rolling Stone magazine convened a panel of experts to assess the situation in Iraq. The panel, which included such policy luminaries as Zbigniew Brzezinski (Jimmy Carter’s national security advisor) and Richard Clarke (counter-terrorism advisor to four presidents), concluded that the war in Iraq is lost. In the course of the discussion, Bob Graham, former chair of the Senate Intelligence Committee, made the following comment: “This administration seems to be getting ready to make—at a much more significant, escalated level—the same mistake we made in Iran that we made in Iraq. If Iraq has been a disaster, this would be multiple times Iraq. The extent to which this could be the horror of the twenty-first century is hard to exaggerate.”

 

Recent crucial events include the passing of the UN-imposed deadline for Iran to halt uranium enrichment, the stationing by the US of two aircraft carrier battle groups—the Eisenhower and the Stennis—in the Persian Gulf, a meeting in Baghdad attended by delegations from both Iran and the US, and the imposition of toughened economic sanctions by the UN Security Council.

 

The conjunction of the negotiations in Baghdad over regional issues (the US cannot extricate itself from Iraq without help from Iran and Syria) with the successful drive for increased UN economic sanctions (a drive led, of course, by the US) suggests that conflicting policies are being pursued in Washington. This appearance may result from an intentional effort to pressure the Iranians at the bargaining table. However, another interpretation of the situation is gaining ground among curious observers—that there is no single pilot steering the US ship of state, and that at least two groups are struggling to control the wheel

 

... If an attack does ensue, the immediate consequences could be moderate to catastrophic—with the moderate effects being more likely, since everyone has had time to think through the various scenarios and is likely to follow through on scripted actions and responses. The longer-term prognosis is not as favorable, as those scripted responses go only so far. The US, Europe, Russia, China, and India all have vital interests in the region, and a general explosion of Sunni-Shia violence could draw these interested parties into conflict. At the very least, we are likely to see an expansion of the chronic violence in Iraq spreading outward throughout the Middle East and perhaps Central Asia as well, with an arc of chaos extending from Pakistan to Saudi Arabia. The worst case is painful to contemplate. If the US and/or Israel follow through on their implied threats to deal militarily with Iran, this may constitute the most dangerous and fateful international gamble in decades.>>

 

**********************************************************************************************************

 

3/         Labour and Skills Crisis Could Stall Oil and Gas Investment Boom        (Booz Allen Hamilton, 24 Aug 2006)

 

http://www.boozallen.com/capabilities/Industries/industries_article/10839857

 

Comment:  ODAC News has covered this BAH report before, via media articles, but this is a link to the actual report (free), released last August 2006. It spells out why a shortage of workers in the oil and gas industry is likely to be a long-term problem (10 years minimum). Figure B says it all. A relatively short and easy read.

 

Article:  From the industrial platforms of oil rigs to air-conditioned design offices, the oil and gas industry is confronted with a shortage of brawn and brains so severe that it threatens to stall exploration and production growth around the world. In recent years while investment levels have been growing by 10 percent per annum, the industry has shrunk its direct labour force and diluted the quality of skills available (see figure A).

 

The talent challenge is not new. At the end of the eighties, skills shortages in the North Sea oil and gas industry hit the headlines, the close of the nineties saw major lay-offs particularly in the US, but it is over the last 12 to 18 months that a confluence of events, including oil prices, planned investments and industry demographics have stretched industry resources globally to breaking point.

 

... At present, the average employee working for a major operator or service company is 46 to 49 years old, according to the Interstate Oil and Gas Compact Commission (IOGCC) in the United States.

“With the average retirement age for the industry being 55 years, it is obvious that the industry faces a crisis in the next 7 to 10 years as more than half of the employee base leaves the work force,” said the commission’s Blue Ribbon Task Force.

 

... Further, Douglas C. Nester, CEO of F-W Oil Exploration, notes:

“Our ability to increase the workforce and replenish the experience base is very limited. Twenty years of contraction, including the loss of more than 500,000 employees, has deterred a new generation of potential workers from entering our business.”

 

... Those let go are gone for ever and short-term consulting or rehires are never quite the same. It takes a minimum of 3 years to develop basic industry operating competence and 10 years plus in many professional disciplines. There is little hope of reinforcements in the near future from traditional sources. Today, there are some 1,700 people studying petroleum engineering in 17 US universities compared with over 11,000 in 34 universities in 1993.

 

... In new investment hot-spots, such as Canada and Qatar, some companies are looking to buy their way out of the crisis, notably poaching qualified staff from other firms. For example, a national oil company recently lured seven experienced petroleum engineers from a joint venture in the Middle East simply by doubling their salaries and other benefits. Similarly, the president of an international oil company in Beijing was lamenting his need to fight off individuals within his own company trying to lure his best people away; and a talent manager in a fast-growing UK-based oil and gas independent commented: “it’s ridiculous, we’re campaigning as hard internally for people as externally.”

 

... Continuing overheating across many areas of the oil and gas industry indicate that the labour shortages are here to stay.

 

... There are too few experienced people across the industry to support operations, growth and the execution of all major projects planned.

 

Conclusion

 

Faced with one of the biggest periods of expansion in its history, the global oil and gas industry is already being held back by its failure to attract, recruit and retain highly skilled staff. This is true from rig workers to senior scientists and engineers. Through short-term thinking and a belief that required staff can be bought, the oil and gas industry has stretched its resource base to breaking point.

 

Some companies have attempted to get around the crisis by poaching talent from other firms or leaning heavily on the “old hands”, but these are at best stop-gap measures...

 

**********************************************************************************************************

 

4/         World Oil Production Close To Peak    (Science Daily, Fri 30 Mar)

 

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/03/070330100802.htm

 

Article:  In a worst-case scenario, global oil production may reach its peak next year, before starting to decline. In a best-case scenario, this peak would not be reached until 2018. These are the estimates made by Fredrik Robelius, whose doctoral dissertation estimates future oil production on the basis of the largest oil fields. The dissertation will be publicly defended at Uppsala University in Sweden on March 30.

 

Fredrik Robelius bases his forecasts on studies of global oil reserves, historical production, and new finds. He focuses on the very largest oil fields, so-called giant fields, which produce a total of at least 500 million barrels of oil.

 

Giant fields comprise only about one percent of all oil fields in the world, but they nevertheless account for more than 60 percent of total production. Unfortunately, the trend is heading downward when it comes to new giant-field discoveries, both in terms of the number of fields and the volume of the fields located. The majority of the largest giant fields are found around the Persian Gulf and are more than 50 years old.

 

“The dominance of giant fields in global oil production supports the thesis that they will be crucial to what future production will look like," says Fredrik Robelius.

 

... To be sure that the future production of a field will wind up inside the interval of the model, Robelius used both pessimistic and optimistic estimates. Then he combined the results from the model with field forecasts for deep-water production, new finds, oil sand in Canada, and heavy oil in Venezuela to construct his forecasts.

 

“All cases studies show that global oil production will begin to drop off at roughly the same time as the giant fields. According to the most pessimistic scenario, the peak will be reached in 2008, whereas the most optimistic scenario, assumed to follow a 1.4-percent annual increase in demand, places the peak in 2018."

 

**********************************************************************************************************

 

5/         Shell Oil exec urges policy change     (Montgomery Advertiser, Fri 16 Mar)

 

http://www.montgomeryadvertiser.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070316/BUSINESS/703160318/1003

 

Article:  … Hofmeister [The president of Shell Oil Co., John Hofmeister] predicted gas prices will continue to increase unless supply or demand pres­sures are relieved.

 

He said an energy crisis is on the horizon because crude and natural gas are more costly and harder to obtain, and petroleum from nontraditional sources, such as oil shale or oil sands, can't meet demand.

 

He said that shortage will make way for alternative energy sources, such as biofuels, wind, sun, hydrogen cells and nuclear power…

 

**********************************************************************************************************

 

6/         New Book:  The Last Oil Shock: A Survival Guide to the Imminent Extinction of Petroleum Man

 

David Strahan's new Peak Oil book, The Last Oil Shock: A Survival Guide to the Imminent Extinction of Petroleum Man, has just been published. David spent two years writing and researching the book. In addition to covering the basics of Peak Oil, it also covers political issues - why is it that Peak Oil is such an obvious problem to the Peak Oil community, but politicians and business are not interested? If you buy the book from Amazon (UK), you get 40% off the normal retail price (see the LastOilShock website, below). Synopsis: "This may be the most important book you or anyone else will read in the next fifty years. Assuming humanity survives that long. Draining the lifeblood of industrial civilization, the terminal decline of oil and gas production will spark a crisis far more dangerous than international terrorism, and just as urgent as climate change. World leaders know it, so why aren't they telling? The last oil shock is the secret behind the crises in Iraq and Iran, the reason your gas bill is going through the roof, the basis of a secret deal cooked up in Texas between George Bush and Tony Blair, the cause of an imminent and unprecedented economic collapse, and the reason you may soon be kissing your car keys and boarding pass goodbye. David Strahan explains how we reached this critical state, how the silence of governments, oil companies and environmentalists conspires to keep the public in the dark, what it means for energy policy, and what you can do to protect yourself and your family from the ravages of the last oil shock."

The Last Oil Shock website

The Last Oil Shock interactive depletion atlas

Video - The Last Oil Shock on YouTube

Book review : The Last Oil Shock by David Strahan by James Howard, PowerSwitch

**********************************************************************************************************

 

7/         Branch of US Government Releases Report On Peak Oil   (ODAC Bulletin Board, Sat 31 Mar)

 

http://www.odac-info.org/

 

ArticleAlthough the US Government itself does not recognise Peak Oil as an imminent problem, a branch of it has just released a report on the issue. The US Government Accountability Office (GAO) issued a peak oil report, CRUDE OIL - Uncertainty about Future Oil Supply Makes It Important to Develop a Strategy for Addressing a Peak and Decline in Oil Production on 29 March 2007 that warned peak could occur any time between now and 2040 and that the US government was totally unprepared. From the report’s Conclusion:

“The prospect of a peak in oil production presents problems of global proportion whose consequences will depend critically on our preparedness. The consequences would be most dire if a peak occurred soon, without warning, and were followed by a sharp decline in oil production because alternative energy sources, particularly for transportation, are not yet available in large quantities. Such a peak would require sharp reductions in oil consumption, and the competition for increasingly scarce energy would drive up prices, possibly to unprecedented levels, causing severe economic damage.”

What makes it more difficult for the US Government, politicians and industry to ignore this report is that it comes from the GAO. From Wikipedia:

"The Government Accountability Office (GAO) is the non-partisan audit, evaluation, and investigative arm of Congress, and an agency in the Legislative Branch of the United States Government. The GAO was established by the Budget and Accounting Act of 1921. This Act required the head of GAO to "investigate, at the seat of government or elsewhere, all matters relating to the receipt, disbursement, and application of public funds, and shall make to the President...and to Congress...reports (and) recommendations looking to greater economy or efficiency in public expenditures". According to GAO's current mission statement, the agency exists to support the Congress in meeting its Constitutional responsibilities and to help improve the performance and ensure the accountability of the federal government for the benefit of the American people."

At least one spokesperson has said in the past that the UK government saw no point in investigating Peak Oil since the USA had two such studies under way (this GAO study and the ongoing National Petroleum Council Global Oil and Gas Study, the final report of which is due out this summer). Now that the GAO study has been published paints a gloomy picture, it remains to be seen whether the UK government will react in a positive manner, i.e. one consistent with national survival.

The full report (PDF, 1.1 Mb)

Highlights

The Energy Bulletin website has lots of other useful links, including video of Matt Simmons discussing Peak Oil on CNBC.

The report was instigated by US Representative Roscoe Bartlett, well known in the USA as a leading Peak Oil campaigner - see Bartlett elaborates on GAO peak oil report

**********************************************************************************************************