ODAC
News
Sunday 24
June
The Oil
Depletion Analysis Centre
Coal
1a/
Science Panel Finds
Fault With Estimates of [US] Coal
Supply (NY Times, Fri
21 Jun)
1b/ Major
Boost Needed in Federal Support for Coal R&D ([US]
Events
2/ Australia: Dr Roger Bezdek in Australia, 19-28 June
2007 (ASPO-Australia, June
2007)
Economy
3a/ Fire sale at Bear Stearns alarms Wall Street as hedge funds
plunge (The Independent, Thu 21
Jun)
3b/ Hamish
McRae: The global squeeze on monetary conditions may not be over
quickly (The Independent, Thu 21
Jun)
4/ Rate
Rise Pushes Housing, Economy to `Blood Bath' (Bloomberg, Wed 20
Jun)
Peak
Oil
5/ Oil
Is Not Well (The American
Spectator, Thu 07 Jun)
10/ Another CEO
goes public on PO being passed with strong
recommendation (ATI Petroleum Press Release, Fri 22
Jun)
Natural Gas /
6a/ Now Russia
tries to hit Exxon deal (Telegraph, Fri 21
Jun)
6b/ Gazprom
bid to cut off China gas (BBC News, Tue 19
Jun)
7a/ BP
sells Siberia stake to Gazprom (BBC News, Fri 22
Jun)
7b/ Kremlin
marches on with Kovykta buy-out (Financial
Times, Fri 22 Jun)
7c/ Gazprom
takes over BP project (IHT, Fri 22
Jun)
8/ Russia to reform national economy to get rid of oil dependence
[anti-ODAC
propaganda]
(Pravda, Fri 22 Jun)
Energy
Efficiency
9/ US
must warm to energy efficiency (Financial Times, Thu 21
Jun)
**********************************************************************************************************
1a/
Science Panel Finds Fault With
Estimates of [US] Coal Supply (NY Times,
Fri 21 Jun)
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/06/21/business/21coal.html?_r=1&ref=business&oref=slogin
Comment:
Article: The
With domestic production of oil, gas
and uranium far below peaks, coal has been promoted by elected officials and
energy experts as the only bright spot in the national fuel supply picture. But
as Congress considers billions of dollars in aid for projects to make gasoline
and diesel substitutes from coal, and to build coal-fired plants that would
capture their own carbon emissions, the study said that estimates of coal
reserves were unreliable.
“There is probably sufficient coal
to meet the nation’s needs for more than 100 years at current rates of
consumption,” the study said. “However, it is not possible to confirm the
often-quoted assertion that there is a sufficient supply of coal for the next
250 years.”
The 250-year estimate was made in
the 1970s and was based on the assumption that 25 percent of the coal that had
been located was recoverable with current technology and at current prices, said
one member of the study group, Edward S. Rubin, a professor of environmental
engineering and science at
But he said that more recent studies
by the United States Geological Survey showed that at least in some areas, only
5 percent of the coal was recoverable with today’s technology and at current
prices. The 100-year forecast was based on current consumption rates, about 1.1
billion tons a year. By 2030, the rate of coal consumption could be 70 percent
higher or 50 percent lower than it is now, the study
found...
1b/
Major Boost Needed in Federal
Support for Coal R&D
([US]
http://nationalacademies.org/morenews/20070620.html
Comment: This is the
report referred to in item 1a above. The full report costs $US36-42.3, depending
on version, but the crux of the report is available free, in the Report Brief (PDF, 2.46 Mb, 4 pages). This is the fourth
report in as many months suggesting global coal reserves may be considerably
less than commonly believed, except that this report suggests taking up to 10
years to determine an accurate estimate of
Article: From page 2 of the Report Brief (emphasis
in bold ODAC’s):
Accurate and comprehensive estimates
of national coal reserves are essential for a coherent national energy strategy,
particularly for community, workforce, and infrastructure planning. Although the
Present estimates of coal reserves—
which take into account location, quality, recoverability, and transportation
issues—are based upon methods that have not been updated since their inception
in 1974, and much of the input data were compiled in the early 1970s. Recent programs to assess coal recoverability in
limited areas using updated methods indicate that only a small fraction of
previously estimated reserves are actually recoverable. Such findings
emphasize the need for a reinvigorated coal reserve assessment program using
modern methods and technologies.
A coordinated federal-state-industry
initiative to determine the magnitude and characteristics of the nation’s
recoverable coal reserves, using modern mapping, coal characterization, and
database technologies, should be instituted with the goal of providing policy
makers with a comprehensive accounting of national coal reserves within 10 years. The report estimates that
such an initiative, which should be lead by the U.S. Geological Survey and
involve participation by the Energy Information Administration at DOE, states,
and industry, will require additional funding of approximately $10 million per
year.
From the News Release (emphasis in bold
ODAC’s):
To formulate national energy
policies, federal policymakers need accurate estimates of the amount, location,
and quality of mineable coal. Such estimates are particularly important
for community, workforce, and infrastructure planning. It is clear that there is enough coal at current rates
of production to meet anticipated needs through 2030, and probably enough for
100 years, the committee said. However, it is not possible to
confirm the often-quoted assertion that there is a sufficient supply for the
next 250 years.
**********************************************************************************************************
2/
http://www.aspo-australia.org.au/content/view/82
Event
Details: Dr Roger Bezdek's
Australian tour is underway. On Thursday 21st June, he provided the keynote
speech at a logistics and supply chain conference in
ITINERARY:
Tue 19th June:
Wed 20th June:
Thu 21st June -
Mon 25th June -
Tue 26th June -
Wed 27th June -
Thu 28th June -
Contact Bruce.Robinson (at)
ASPO-Australia.org.au or 0427 398 708 for details.
Comment: ASPO-Australia
has also added links for media coverage of Roger’s tour to their website. From
what I can tell media coverage of Peak Oil in
**********************************************************************************************************
3a/
Fire sale at Bear Stearns alarms
Wall Street as hedge funds plunge (The
Independent, Thu 21 Jun)
http://news.independent.co.uk/business/news/article2686929.ece
Comment: Not directly
related to energy, but the financial system we have. One concern with Peak Oil
is that due to rising oil prices, and therefore inflation and interest rates,
Article: A planned fire
sale of assets from two crippled hedge funds has been attracting the attention
of a nervous Wall Street, for fear it could reveal billions of dollars of hidden
losses across the financial system.
Bear Stearns, the investment bank
formed in 1923, was last night still struggling to save its two funds, which got
into trouble after the
The two funds had raised about
$1.5bn from investors but were using debt and derivative instruments to make
bets of about $30bn on the financial markets. Its investments were mainly in
complex financial instruments backed in part by sub-prime
mortgages.
The number of sub-prime borrowers -
Americans given high-priced home loans, despite being deemed a poor credit risk
- who have got into arrears or had their homes repossessed has spiked to a
record level, and the effects of rising defaults are rippling through the
financial system.
The mortgages have been parcelled
together with other investments into products called collateralised debt
obligations (CDOs), which are sold on piece-by-piece to other investors. Their
sheer complexity is such that their value is usually calculated using
mathematical models rather than open-market prices.
Demand for new CDOs backed by
sub-prime mortgages has already dried up. If the price existing assets fetch in
an auction proves disappointing, hundreds of banks, hedge funds and other
investors could discover they are sitting on losses they did not realise. Hank
Paulson, US Treasury secretary, warned yesterday that there would continue to be
"after-shocks", but insisted they would be contained and would not damage the
overall economy.
Late on Tuesday, Merrill Lynch
rejected a rescue plan for the two funds that would have involved Bear Stearns
putting in more money. Instead, it began yesterday handing out details of some
$800m in CDOs and other assets that it had seized and planned to auction.
Deutsche Bank was among other creditors rumoured to be doing the same. The
The funds were set up and run by
Ralph Cioffi, a Bear Stearns mortgage-bond veteran, who successfully auctioned
off $4bn of higher-quality assets last week as he battled to satisfy creditors
and save the fund.
Investors have been clamouring for
their money back since sub-prime mortgage market bets went awry in April and the
fund suddenly found itself down 23 per cent from the start of the
year.
The first two lenders to unwind
their positions, Goldman Sachs and Bank of America, reportedly did so directly
with Bear Stearns, rather than dumping billions of dollars of bonds on the
market. JP Morgan pulled its auction of seized assets at the last minute
yesterday in order to do the same, but it appeared that Merrill Lynch was going
ahead.
3b/
Hamish McRae: The global squeeze
on monetary conditions may not be over quickly
(The Independent, Thu 21 Jun)
http://news.independent.co.uk/business/comment/article2686885.ece
Comment: The Independent
website is down again, so no quote from article. Hamish is warning that the
increase in interest rates is not over yet (in the
**********************************************************************************************************
4/
Rate Rise Pushes Housing, Economy
to `Blood Bath'
(Bloomberg, Wed 20 Jun)
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601109&sid=adDRCBB5fqZQ&refer=exclusive
Comment: Lengthy article
suggesting that the problems with the
Article: The worst is yet
to come for the
The jump in 30-year mortgage rates
by more than a half a percentage point to 6.74 percent in the past five weeks is
putting a crimp on borrowers with the best credit just as a crackdown in
subprime lending standards limits the pool of qualified buyers. The national
median home price is poised for its first annual decline since the Great
Depression, and the supply of unsold homes is at a record 4.2 million, the
National Association of Realtors reported.
``It's a blood bath,'' said Mark
Kiesel, executive vice president of Newport Beach, California-based Pacific
Investment Management Co., the manager of $668 billion in bond funds. ``We're
talking about a two- to three-year downturn that will take a whole host of
characters with it, from job creation to consumer confidence. Eventually it will
take the stock market and corporate profit.''
Confidence among
**********************************************************************************************************
5/
Oil Is Not
Well
(The American Spectator, Thu 07 Jun)
http://www.spectator.org/dsp_article.asp?art_id=11545
Comment: R. Emmett
Tyrrell, Jr., The American
Spectator, is "adjunct fellow at the Hudson Institute" according to
the article credits, which Wikipedia
describes as "a right-leaning
Article: The presidential
candidates, hustling for their parties' presidential nominations, tell us that
they are going to make us "energy independent." At the same time they also tell
us that $3.00-a-gallon gasoline at the pump is highway robbery. Some announce
that they are going to investigate the oil companies. This is political
schizophrenia. We cannot approach energy independence and maintain cheap oil
prices simultaneously. In fact, in the near future neither goal is possible.
... Thus oil experts such as Boone
Pickens predict $80 a barrel oil by the end of the year. He doubts that the
world can produce more that 85 million barrels a day. That means the price of
gasoline will be even higher than $3.00 a gallon. Verleger predicts $100 a
barrel oil before the end of 2008. Imagine what you will be paying for a gallon
of gas then.
... Peak production of oil, however,
is here and now.
**********************************************************************************************************
6a/
Now
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/money/main.jhtml?xml=/money/2007/06/21/cnexxon121.xml
Article: Exxon-Mobil has
become the latest western oil and gas company to become embroiled in
State-run gas company Gazprom wants
to halt an Exxon-led project from supplying
Exxon, the world's largest oil and
gas company, run by chief executive Rex Tillerson, said yesterday that it was in
talks with Gazprom. "The purpose of the discussions is to find a mutually
acceptable option for the parties involved," Exxon
said.
The
But Gazprom's deputy chief
executive, Alexander Ananenkov, said Exxon's supply deal, which he claimed was
to export 80bn cubic metres of gas a year, would leave
However, analysts say the dispute it
bound up with
Gazprom has its own plans to sell
gas to
Last year, after allegations that
Shell had broken environmental licences at its Sakhalin-2 gas field, Gazprom
took control of the project. If Gazprom gets its way over the Exxon and TNK-BP
projects, the Russian company would exercise total control over supplies to
6b/
Gazprom bid to cut off
http://newsvote.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/6769797.stm
Comment: “But critically,
it means that gas shortages in
Article: Russian energy
giant Gazprom has asked the government to cancel an agreement to pipe large
quantities of gas to
Alexander Ananenkov, the group's
deputy chief executive, said plans to deliver 80bn cubic metres of gas a year to
The gas was due to be exported from
Exxon Mobil's Sakhalin-1 project on
The move could fan fears over
"We consider it necessary for a
directive to be issued and Sakhalin-1 gas to be sold to Gazprom so we could
supply gas to
He claimed that
Gas shortages
If the Russian government responds
to Gazprom's proposal and intervenes in the export agreements on Sakhalin-1,
Such an action will also heighten
concerns over the growing influence of state-run Gazprom and the Kremlin's grip
on its domestic gas industry.
Russian gas accounts for 25% of
supplies to the European Union (EU).
But critically, it means that gas
shortages in
Shell was forced to sell its stake
in the Sakhalin-2 project to Gazprom after pressure from Russian regulators.
And BP is currently waiting to hear
if its licence for the Kovytka gas field in
Analysts say Gazprom could face a
fight in wresting control of Sakhalin-1 from rival Rosneft - the
state-controlled oil firm - which is a shareholder in the project, together with
**********************************************************************************************************
7a/
BP sells
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/6230556.stm
Comment: BP salvages what
it can from the Kovykta gas field TNK-BP project. Not a lot apparently. In item
7c, the IHT article is sceptical the Gazprom-BP joint venture will come to
much.
Article: British oil firm
BP has sold its stake in a Siberian gas field development to Russian
state-controlled firm Gazprom.
BP's Russian joint venture TNK-BP
has agreed to sell Gazprom its majority interests in the giant Kovykta field for
between $700m-$900m (£350m-£450m).
Analysts said this is a fraction of
what TNK-BP's stake is worth, and that it is the latest example of the Kremlin
forcing out Western energy firms.
Kovykta is said to have enough gas
to supply all of
'Historic agreement'
The sale comes after Russian
authorities had put increasing pressure on TNK-BP, saying the firm was not
producing enough gas from the Kovykta field.
Russian officials claimed that under
the terms of its licence, Kovykta should have been producing nine billion cubic
metres of gas per year by 2006, rather than the less than 2.5 billion cubic
metres actually being processed.
TNK-BP said that it could not
produce any more because the local region did not require additional supplies
and it had been denied an export licence.
Similar pressure was put on
Anglo-Dutch energy group Shell last year, before it sold Gazprom its majority
stake in the Sakhalin-2 oil and gas project off
Shell sold its interests in
Sakhalin-2 after Russian authorities continually refused to grant it the
necessary environmental certificates.
Future co-operation
BP said it and TNK-BP were now
looking to invest in projects with Gazprom "in major long-term energy projects
or swap assets around the world".
The firms will set up a joint team
to identify strategic opportunities for investment both overseas and inside
"We will initially be looking for
projects of at least $3bn, but the potential for further growth could be very
significant," said BP chief executive Tony Hayward.
"This historic agreement lays the
ground for powerful co-operation between BP, TNK-BP and Gazprom."
Gazprom is buying TNK-BP's 62.89%
stake in Russia Petroleum, the firm with the licence for the Kovykta gas field.
TNK-BP is also selling Gazprom its
half-share in East Siberian Gas Company, the company constructing the wider
regional gasification project, BP said in a
statement.
7b/
Kremlin marches on with Kovykta
buy-out (Financial Times,
Fri 22 Jun)
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/15bd47b8-20e8-11dc-8d50-000b5df10621,s01=1.html
Comment: Same story from
the FT.
Article: TNK-BP’s deal to
sell its vast Siberian Kovykta gas project to state-controlled Gazprom marks
another big step in the Kremlin’s takeover of the energy sector after months of
government pressure.
But Friday’s agreement for joint
investments by Gazprom and TNK-BP abroad also signals the importance the Kremlin
is placing on the need for its state-owned energy champions to expand abroad and
to retain some foreign investment.
“Both sides knew they had leverage
over each other,” said one person familiar with the
matter.
Instead of pulling TNK-BP’s licence
over production violations at the field, as the Russian government had
threatened to, Gazprom will pay nearly double what TNK-BP has spent on
developing the field so far.
TNK-BP’s efforts to develop the
field had long been stymied by Gazprom’s refusal to join the project on TNK-BP’s
terms.
Without Gazprom, TNK-BP had no real
market for the gas because of the state-controlled gas champion’s monopoly on
export routes.
Because of this, BP had not even
booked the 3,000bn cubic metre field on to its
reserves.
“The last thing the Kremlin wanted
to do was to have a big scandal with BP,” said another person involved in the
process.
“Aside from missile defence and
Estonia, a big part of the tension [between Russia and the west] has been
energy.”
The deal also leaves a window open
for TNK-BP to re-enter the project via an option for a 25 per cent stake in the
business to be exercised within one year.
Some analysts said jittery investors
should be thankful for small mercies. “This is not going to send investors
rushing to invest in Russia, but it’s part of the picture,” said Chris Weafer,
chief strategist at Alfa Bank.
“The Kremlin has acknowledged they
need the involvement of foreign companies if the growth process is to proceed
safely.”
The tie-up with BP for international
joint ventures could provide Gazprom with a vehicle for acquisitions in the UK
gas market, Valery Nesterov, energy analyst at Troika Dialog,
noted.
But Friday’s deal may prove only the
first phase of a broader state takeover of TNK-BP.
Many observers had seen the standoff
over Kovykta as part of a broader campaign of pressure to force TNK-BP’s Russian
shareholders to sell their 50 per cent stake in TNK-BP to state-controlled
majors Gazprom or Rosneft.
One person with knowledge of the
situation said Friday that the restructuring of TNK-BP was “still unfinished
business – the company’s structure is still out of line”, a reference to the
Kremlin’s new paradigm of state control.
By the time TNK-BP uses the option,
the structure of TNK-BP could have changed, the person said.
Alexander Medvedev, Gazprom’s deputy
chief executive, gave the strongest indication of this on Friday when he told
reporters that BP might return to Kovykta at a later date.
“To remain in a monastery one has to
leave it, be purged of sin and return to it,” he
said.
7c/
Gazprom takes over BP
project (IHT, Fri 22
Jun)
http://www.iht.com/articles/2007/06/22/business/bp.php
Comment: Same story from
the IHT. Lengthy article.
Article: … Analysts,
however, said BP lost a major asset, though the company had not booked the
reserves because the field was not fully developed.
Still, the vague value of the new
strategic partnership agreement contrasted with the immediate loss at the
Kovykta field - a project BP cultivated for a decade, through two Russian
administrations, with an eye on the booming energy market in
"BP clearly got fleeced," said Alex
Turkeltaub, a managing partner at Frontier Strategy Group, a
Turkeltaub downplayed the value to
BP of bringing Gazprom in as a partner at projects outside of
**********************************************************************************************************
8/
http://english.pravda.ru/russia/economics/93835-0
Comment: The Russian
Soviet-era newspaper Pravda seems
to have taken exception to the recent Independent article promoting ODAC's point of view on global
oil reserves. Apparently, ODAC is linked to the White House. This is news to
ODAC.
Article: British
scientists recently released a report warning that world oil supplies could run
out faster than expected. The scientists seem to have been commissioned by the
White House to come up with a forecast that justifies
... However, the scientists at the
Oil Depletion Analysis Centre believe that global oil production is set to peak
in the next four years, reaching the highest level in 2011. A steep decline in
production is expected to occur thereafter, warn the scientists. One can get the
impression that these “brand-new” assessments have been carried out at the
recommendation of
**********************************************************************************************************
9/
US must warm to energy
efficiency
(Financial Times, Thu 21 Jun)
Comment: Full article for
FT subscribers only.
Article: Between record
petrol prices at home, growing geopolitical instability abroad and mounting
concern over climate change, the case for fundamental energy reform has never
been stronger. Yet the
New research by the McKinsey Global
Institute finds that a concerted effort to boost energy productivity – or the
level of output achieved from the energy consumed – could have spectacular
results. If policymakers embrace a new drive to improve energy productivity,
relying on existing technologies, the
**********************************************************************************************************
10/
Another CEO goes public on
http://www.companynewsgroup.com/communique.asp?co_id=121453
Comment: This is an odd
Press Release in that the title, “ATI Petroleum annuncia quotazione su
NYSE/Euronext e apre ufficio in Francia”, and first two paragraphs are in
Italian(?), then switches to English end of second paragraph. ATIP is the
Petroleum branch of the US-based ATI Group. An ODAC News subscriber
states:
“Another CEO goes public on Peak Oil
being passed with strong recommendation. OK he has got interests in Nuclear but
he seems to fully understand value of Oil &
Gas.”
Note that ATIP is preparing to list
on the stock market: “ATIP expands its capital raising efforts and decided to
list its stock on the Euronext market rather than in the
Article: Dr. Dinh [Dr. Huu
Duc Dinh, Chairman and CEO] added : "Global energy demand is soaring and we
believe the rate of change will only increase as populous nations in Asia and
Africa continue rapidly developing their domestic economies," "Despite the
long-term promise of fusion, solar, wind and other alternative energy solutions,
the reality is that the world runs on energy from coal, petroleum and nuclear
power. The days of peak oil production have passed and supplies will only grow
scarcer as demand increases. Oil and gas must be saved for necessary activities
like being the feedstock for fertilizer instead of being used for electricity
generation."
**********************************************************************************************************