ODAC News
Monday 10 Dec
The Oil Depletion Analysis Centre
New Peak Oil Report
1/ A Failure of Leadership
(ODAC [Global Witness], Fri 07 Dec)
IEA, Oil Demand / Supply
2/ IEA: oil demand has
surpassed supply
(The Oil Drum:
LNG Supplies - Trinidad and
3/ Energy company
preaches restraint on natural gas projects - Audit puts 12-year life on
reserves (Jamaica Gleaner, Fri 07 Dec)
Natural Gas / Electricity Prices -
4a/ 'Ominous warning sign’ as
British Gas raises tariffs (The Times, Wed 05 Dec)
4b/ Higher energy prices feared
in new year (The Times, Fri
07 Dec)
Economy -
5a/ Warning of slump as Bank
cuts rates to 5.5pc
(The Telegraph, Fri 07 Dec)
5b/ Apocalypse now?
(BBC News [Evamonics], Thu 06 Dec)
Economy - Other
6a/ Wall Street's sub-prime loss
could soar as bond insurers face shortfall (The Times, Thu 06 Dec)
6b/ UBS grabs new investors
after $10bn credit hit
(The Telegraph, Mon 10 Dec)
6c/ Decoupling dies as half the
globe hits crunch (The Telegraph, Mon 10 Dec)
6d/ Mortgage Meltdown
(Sanders Research Associates Ltd / SF Gate, Mon 10 Dec)
Copper Theft -
7/ Rail police: cable
crime is biggest threat after terror (The Times,
Tue 04 Dec)
Rising Oil Consumption – Oil producing Countries
8/ Oil-rich nations
tapping more of their own resources (International
Herald Tribune [NY Times], Sun 09 Dec)
Economy – South America and
9/ Seven South American
countries forming their own development bank / Iranian currency issues
(Le Monde, Mon 10 Dec)
Transport post-Peak Oil
10/ Transport and post-Peak Oil
(ODAC, Mon 03 Dec)
**********************************************************************************************************
1/ A Failure of Leadership (ODAC
[Global Witness], Fri 07 Dec)
http://www.odac-info.org/
Bulletin Board
Comment: This was added to the ODAC
Bulletin Board last Friday.
Article: Global Witness is a group that: "exposes the corrupt exploitation of natural resources and international trade systems, to drive campaigns that end impunity, resource-linked conflict, and human rights and environmental abuses." (see About Us). Over the last year or two they have been paying increasing attention to Peak Oil. This week they launched their first report on Peak Oil. Simon Taylor from Global Witness explains:
We have just released our new short paper - "A Failure of
Leadership: How Action on Climate Change Will be Overwhelmed by the Energy
Crisis". It is authored by Global Witness, but published by Global Witness
and the Heinrich Böll Foundation (HBF), with HBF distributing it at the UN's
climate change meeting in
It is very short, very selective and very simplified - but
this is because of space constraints, the opportunity it represented [i.e.
For the moment, the paper should be considered as an extension of Global Witness' work on the role of natural resources in funding conflict. As energy availability declines, the world faces an increased risk of conflict - the ultimate war over natural resources - as powerful industrialised countries engage in an escalating competition for energy supplies. Such competition will put at risk hard won natural resource governance reforms such as the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI), one of the keys to creating government accountability around extractive industry revenues. The scale of the impending crisis of energy supplies is little understood amongst policy experts, let alone properly acknowledged by politicians, and there are no effective measures being put in place to address the situation. Furthermore, the resultant geopolitical and economic impacts of a declining energy supply, will likely invade the political space required to address the climate crisis.
Global Witness exposes and breaks the links between the exploitation of natural resources, conflict, corruption and human rights abuses. In the twelve years since we launched our first campaign we have created a growing international awareness that poor governance and unaccountability in relation to the exploitation of natural resources leads not only to environmental degradation, but also to conflict, entrenched poverty and massive human suffering.
Report: A Failure of Leadership: How Action on Climate Change Will be Overwhelmed by the Energy Crisis (PDF, 446 Kb)
**********************************************************************************************************
2/ IEA: oil demand has surpassed supply
(The Oil Drum:
http://www.theoildrum.com/node/3331
Article: The energy watchdog of the
OECD countries, the International Energy Agency (IEA), recently started to talk
about looming oil shortages. The high oil price of today will remain is the
message they are spreading. We need to save more oil, invest more in increasing
oil production and upscale alternatives. However, the IEA does not see a peak
in worldwide oil production occurring in the coming decades. Based on the
expectation that large amounts of oil will be discovered, not yet on the radar
of oil companies worldwide. This new stance follows below from the translated
transcript of an interview recently broadcasted on the Dutch television channel
RTL-Z with Aad van Bohemen, the Director of Crisis Management at the IEA.
What is the significance of the current crisis on the
oil market?
“The situation on the oil market is worrisome in the
sense of there being more demand than supply. This does not mean that we should
panic because of an acute shortage of oil, there is sufficient oil in the
world. There is production capacity that can be brought to the market by the
oil producing countries. But this capacity should be brought to the market to
meet supply. So the situation is on overall worrisome, but it is not yet time to
panic.”
[plus another 15 questions]
**********************************************************************************************************
3/ Energy company preaches restraint on natural gas projects - Audit puts
12-year life on reserves
(Jamaica Gleaner, Fri 07 Dec)
http://www.jamaica-gleaner.com/gleaner/efg/20071207/Regionalnews/reg2.html
Comment:
Article: Chairman and chief executive
officer of BP Trinidad and
"We have to exercise restraint, because we cannot
allow growth to so drive us that we get so far ahead of exploration potential
that we have projects but no gas," Riley said in Port-of-Spain.
... A January 2007 audit from Houston-based Ryder
Scott shows that the country's gas reserves are depleting rapidly and suggests
more discoveries are needed quickly to sustain the expanded gas needs of the
country.
"
Based on a production rate of 4.5 billion cubic feet
per day, the gas will last only 12 more years unless new discoveries are made.
The country's '3P' or proved, possible and probable
reserves were estimated at 31.04 tcf, down from the 34.87 tcf identified in
2005.
Proved reserves in 2007 totalled 17.05 tcf, possible
was placed at another 6.23 tcf, and probable at 7.76 tcf.
...
Additional sources needed
By 2016, daily natural gas production is estimated to
increase to 5.9 bcf, split 53 per cent LNG and 47 per cent to the domestic
market
To meet its own contractual obligations, BPTT's main
challenge in the medium to long term is finding additional resources every year
to sustain its 500,000 barrels of oil equivalent a day output.
"The challenge being to put one trillion cubic feet
of gas behind the pipe every year going forward because that's what we have to
replace as a business," said Riley.
BPTT can comfortably maintain the 500,000 barrels up
to 2011 with its Mango and Cashima platforms delivering additional resources,
said the CEO.
... "We believe we understand the extent of the
basin; we have a fairly good idea of the size," said Riley, adding that
BPTT was expecting no big hits.
"We will find gas, but we will not find anything
in the sort of large numbers that we used to find in the last decade or
so," he said.
"The conversation around exploration, therefore,
changes, merely from exploring to exploring somewhat with a lot more appraisal
to prove up and pull through the 'yet to find' - the possible and probable
resources. We are, therefore, tending to what people call in the industry, the
plateau phase of the growth life cycle, and the transition from growth to the
sustained mode."
**********************************************************************************************************
4a/ 'Ominous warning sign’ as British Gas raises tariffs
(The Times, Wed 05 Dec)
Comment: That the
Article: British households suffered a
fresh blow to their strained finances yesterday as British Gas said that it was
lifting the price of a key energy tariff by up to 15 per cent, prompting fears
of a wider increase in gas and electricity bills in the new year.
The majority of the ten million gas and six million
electricity customers of Centrica, the British Gas owner, who are on standard
or online tariffs will not be affected, but industry experts say that the news
is a harbinger of price rises to come in 2008.
Mark Todd, a director at energy-helpline.com, described
it was “an ominous warning sign”.
Tim Wolfenden, the head of home services at
uSwitch,com, said: “The fact that prices are higher now for this product . . .
suggests other suppliers won’t be able to hold back from further rises next
year.”...
4b/ Higher energy prices feared in new year
(The Times, Fri 07 Dec)
Article: EDF and E.ON are among
several energy groups that are understood to be considering price rises of up to
10 per cent, possibly as early as January. One industry source said: “It is not
a question of if, so much as when. Once one goes, they will all go.”
In recent months, energy suppliers have been hit by a
combination of rising distribution costs related to infrastructure improvements
and soaring prices in wholesale gas markets, which also influence electricity
prices.
Since February, annual forward gas prices for 2008
have risen 42 per cent from 33p a therm to 47p a therm - about 10p more than
industry forecasts, according to analysts. Spot prices have risen 55 per cent
over the past year to about 42p a therm from 27p.
Energy broker Catalyst Consumer Services has forecast
that retail energy prices could rise by up to 10 per cent in the new year, a
margin that would drive average
**********************************************************************************************************
5a/ Warning of slump as Bank cuts rates to 5.5pc
(The Telegraph, Fri 07 Dec)
Article: The Bank of England admitted
for the first time yesterday that the economy is facing a serious slow-down
because of the global credit crisis.
After announcing the first interest rate cut for two
years, the bank issued a statement saying that growth had begun to slow, with
serious potential knock-on effects for the economy's overall output.
The warning, the starkest yet from the bank, came as
the western world's leading economic authority issued a warning on
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and
Development said one of the biggest risks now facing
With the City facing a major cut in jobs and bonus
payments,
5b/ Apocalypse now? (BBC News [Evamonics], Thu 06
Dec)
http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/thereporters/evandavis/2007/12/apocalypse_now.html
Comment: Thu 06 Dec I was surprised to
hear Evan Davis (BBC Economics Editor) use the ‘A’ word on the 10 pm BBC News, i.e.
‘apocalyptic’. He was talking about the
Article: Bank rate down... No surprise
there, given the evidence that market interest rates are higher than intended
and a slowdown is gathering pace.
Is the world saved? Can we now all relax?
Probably not. The main challenges remain, and the risks
are sufficiently worrying that even if one tries to disregard apocalyptic
language about recession, this is a pretty good time to allow oneself a bit of
scary hyperbole.
For the most cogent example of that, see Anatole Kaletsky in The Times today.
My own personal view is that things may well go quite
well next year. However, there is a sufficient risk they will go badly or very
badly...
**********************************************************************************************************
6a/ Wall Street's sub-prime loss could soar as bond insurers face shortfall
(The Times, Thu 06 Dec)
Article: The combined loss suffered by
Wall Street banks on bonds backed by high-risk sub-prime mortgages could more
than double to about $110 billion (£54 billion) after Moody’s, the ratings
agency, gave warning that America’s biggest bond insurers were “somewhat
likely” to run short of funds.
Moody’s is conducting a review of MBIA, Ambac and five
of America’s other biggest securities insurers, which guarantee a mortgage bond’s
interest payments in the event of a default on the home loans that back them.
In a development that will ricochet across the bond markets,
the agency gave warning yesterday that the recent surge in defaults on
sub-prime mortgages would probably leave some of America’s biggest bond
insurers with insufficient funds to make good the payments that will be
required on some of the bonds they insure.
Moody’s added that this probable funding shortfall
threatened the AAA credit rating of bond insurers such as MBIA, Ambac, Security
Capital Insurance and Financial Guaranty Insurance.
A decline in the bond insurers’ ratings would, in turn,
wipe tens of billions of dollars off the value of the combined mortgage bond
holdings of the Wall Street firms because it would send a clear signal to the
market that their ability to guarantee interest payments had deteriorated.
These losses would be on top of both the $50 billion
hit that they have already suffered as a result of declines in the value of the
mortgage-backed securities that they own and the forecasts of further
substantial losses on these portfolios next year...
6b/ UBS grabs new investors after $10bn credit hit
(The Telegraph, Mon 10 Dec)
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/money/main.jhtml?xml=/money/2007/12/10/bcnubs210.xml
Article: Swiss banking giant UBS has
been forced to write off a further $10bn (£4.9bn) in sub-prime losses and sell
stakes to two new investors as the credit crisis worsens.
In a surprise statement this morning, UBS told
investors it had agreed to raise 19.4 billion Swiss francs (£8.2bn) in new
capital by selling stakes to a the Government of Singapore and an unnamed
investor in the Middle East.
The shock announcement by UBS comes less than three
months after the lender revealed it had plunged to a third-quarter loss and
announced a raft of management changes following its exposure to the troubled
sub-prime
The bank also scrapped an earlier forecast that it
would make a fourth quarter profit and now expects to record a loss for 2007 as
a whole...
6c/ Decoupling dies as half the globe hits crunch
(The Telegraph, Mon 10 Dec)
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/money/main.jhtml?xml=/money/2007/12/10/bcnambrose11.xml
Comment: Ambrose Evans-Pritchard,
International Business Editor. His articles on the economy get more apocalyptic
by the week, but he does back up his views with solid statistics. Colin
Campbell, and others, often talk of Peak Oil leading to the Second Great
Depression. I have seen several articles on the sub-prime crisis/scam and its
fallout leading down the same road. While there are no direct comparisons with first
Great Depression here, Ambrose does allude: “Mr Paulson's New Deal may at least
reduce systemic risk”.
Article: The rising economies of Asia
are too small and deformed to rescue world growth as
The seven pillars of global demand over the last year
- measured by current account deficits - have been the
Assumptions that it will weather a global shock are
"likely to be wrong, perhaps dramatically."
... In
Thomas Mayer,
"This could go beyond just a normal recession. It
could turn into a real economy-wide crunch that we cannot stop," he said
... For now, consensus has settled on the view that
subprime losses will total $500bn, and crimp lending by $2 trillion as bank
multiples kick into reverse.
This assumes there are no more shoes to drop. Yet
shoes are dangling precariously across the global credit system. We may soon
have to add the terms HELOCs and 'monoline insurers' to our crunch lexicon.
HELOCs are home equity loans, the money extracted from
houses to pay bills and keep shopping. Many borrowers pushed their debt to 110pc
of house values at the top of the bubble.
... US Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson confronts the
very real danger of a credit implosion spiralling into a full-blown depression.
Given the risks, he can be forgiven for pushing through a rescue plan last week
that amounts to a flagrant abuse of contract law and capitalist principles.
... Mr Paulson's New Deal may at least reduce systemic
risk. Frozen rates concentrate losses in the lower tiers of mortgage debt, but
rescue the upper tiers, which is where the threat lies for the financial
system. Would free marketeers rather see the whole edifice of capitalism burned
to the ground to make their point?
The root cause of this staggering debacle lies in
errors made long ago by the Federal Reserve and fellow sinners. It was they who
inflated the credit bubble by holding interest rates too low for too long. It
was they who lulled their nations into suicidal levels of debt.
The strategic failure of a whole generation of
economists, bankers, and policy-makers has been so enormous that it may now
take a strong draught of socialism to save the Western democracies. We start -
but may not end - with the nationalization of Northern Rock.
6d/ Mortgage Meltdown
(Sanders Research Associates Ltd / SF Gate, Mon 10 Dec)
http://www.sandersresearch.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=1328
Comment: Originally in
Article: Interest rate 'freeze' - the
real story is fraud. Bankers pay lip service to families while scurrying to
avert suits, prison
New proposals to ease our great mortgage meltdown keep
rolling in. First the Treasury Department urged the creation of a new fund that
would buy risky mortgage bonds as a tactic to hide what those bonds were really
worth. (Not much.) Then the idea was to use Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to buy
the risky loans, even if it was clear that
Now, just unveiled Thursday, comes the
"freeze," the brainchild of Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson. It
sounds good: For five years, mortgage lenders will freeze interest rates on a
limited number of "teaser" subprime loans. Other homeowners facing
foreclosure will be offered assistance from the Federal Housing Administration.
But unfortunately, the "freeze" is just another
fraud — and like the other bailout proposals, it has nothing to do with
The sole goal of the freeze is to prevent owners of
mortgage-backed securities, many of them foreigners, from suing
The ticking time bomb in the
And, to be sure, fraud is everywhere. It's in the loan
application documents, and it's in the appraisals. There are e-mails and memos
floating around showing that many people in banks, investment banks and appraisal
companies — all the way up to senior management — knew about it.
... The catastrophic consequences of bond investors
forcing originators to buy back loans at face value are beyond the current
media discussion. The loans at issue dwarf the capital available at the largest
U.S. banks combined, and investor lawsuits would raise stunning liability
sufficient to cause even the largest U.S. banks to fail, resulting in massive
taxpayer-funded bailouts of Fannie and Freddie, and even FDIC.
... I suspect that such a group first sat down and
tried to figure out how to protect their financial interests and avoid criminal
liability. And then when they agreed on the plan, they decided to sell it as
"helping working families stay in their homes." That's why these
meetings were secret, and reporters and the public weren't invited.
... This logic is like saying shoppers seeking
bargain-priced soup encourage the grocery store owner to steal it. I mean,
we're talking about criminal fraud here. We are on the cusp of a mammoth
financial crisis, and the Federal Reserve and the U.S. Treasury are trying to
limit the liability of their banking friends under the guise of trying to help
borrowers. At stake is nothing short of the continued existence of the
**********************************************************************************************************
7/ Rail police: cable crime is biggest threat after terror
(The Times, Tue 04 Dec)
Comment: It is probably no coincidence
that an increasing number of items in the newsletter are about the knock-on
effects of high energy and commodity/metals prices, rather than Peak Oil/Gas directly:
“Escalating theft of rail signalling and electrical cabling by criminals
cashing in on the high cost of scrap metal has led Ian Johnston, the Chief Constable
of the British Transport Police, to declare the problem “the second-biggest challenge”
after terrorism.”
Article: Escalating theft of rail
signalling and electrical cabling by criminals cashing in on the high cost of
scrap metal has led Ian Johnston, the Chief Constable of the British Transport Police,
to declare the problem “the second-biggest challenge” after terrorism.
Copper thieves are also targeting electricity
facilities, with Scottish-Power suffering about five break-ins a week at its
substations. The company will brand wire with its name or a code so that scrap
metal merchants can tell if it is stolen. It believes that organised crime is
behind many of the thefts because often several substations are hit at the same
time.
A spokesman for the Energy Networks Association, the industry
body, said: “There has been a massive increase in cable theft over the past 18
months. It is a huge problem. It is hard to establish a national picture, but
some police forces are reporting a 150 per cent increase in cable theft.”
The energy, rail and telecoms industries have joined a
task force led by the Association of Chief Police Officers and British
Transport Police to try to stop the crimes.
It is the first time that a national police task force
has been assembled to tackle commodity theft, a crime more colloquially
associated with lead disappearing from church roofs. It is expected to come
under pressure to call for tougher legislation of the scrap metal industry,
including requiring dealers to fully record purchases and to stop paying
suppliers in cash...
**********************************************************************************************************
8/ Oil-rich nations tapping more of their own resources
(International Herald Tribune [NY Times], Sun 09 Dec)
http://www.iht.com/articles/2007/12/09/business/oil.php?WT.mc_id=newsalert
Comment: When a newspaper like the IHT
/ NY Times interviews experts like Daniel Yergin, you end up with statements like
this: “The trend, though increasingly important, does not necessarily mean there
will be oil shortages”. The IEA, in its July 2007 Medium Term Oil Market Report,
warned of an ‘oil crunch’ by 2012 (it changed its mind in the November-released
World Energy Outlook, to ‘by 2015’. Maybe someone got told off?). It beggars
belief that with the IEA increasingly warning of an oil crunch, soon-ish, and
an increasing number of oil executives queuing up to say global oil production
will never reach 100 Mb/d, that the NY Times / IHT can print such nonsense. The
rest of the article makes some very good points, but stops short of drawing any
conclusions. Reading between the lines, this is probably as close to warning
that Peak Oil might be close as the IHT / NY Times is going to get.
“Perhaps surprisingly, though, some producing
countries have surpassed the
At the end of the day, it does not really matter who
is consuming the oil. If global demand outstrips supply (and it has been for
much of the last 6 months), the price of oil will eventually rocket, and the
economic damage will be done.
The CIBC report mentioned is this one, OPEC’s Growing Call on Itself, also available from the ODAC
website – see the Assessments page.
Article: The economies of many big
oil-exporting countries are growing so fast that their need for energy within
their borders is crimping how much they can sell abroad, adding new strains to
the global oil market.
Experts say the sharp growth, if it continues, means that
several of the world's most important suppliers may need to start importing oil
within a decade to power all the new cars, houses and businesses they are
buying and creating with their oil wealth.
In some cases, the governments of these countries
subsidize gasoline heavily for their citizens, selling it for as little as 7
cents a gallon, or 2 cents a liter, a practice that industry experts say
fosters wasteful habits.
"It is a very serious threat that a lot of major
exporters that we count on today for international oil supply are no longer
going to be net exporters any more in five to 10 years," said Amy Myers
Jaffe, an oil analyst at Rice University in Texas.
The trend, though increasingly important, does not
necessarily mean there will be oil shortages. More likely, experts say, it will
mean big market shifts, with the number of exporting countries shrinking and
unconventional sources like Canadian tar sands becoming more important,
especially for the
... Rising internal demand may offset 40 percent of
the increase in Saudi oil production between now and 2010, while more than half
the projected decline in Iranian exports will be caused by internal
consumption, said a recent report by CIBC World Markets.
... Factors contributing to the trend include
increased industrialization, higher government spending and increasing personal
consumption. According to a World Bank report, economic growth in the Middle
East and North Africa has doubled since the 1990s, and
... Some oil-exporting countries use price controls
and subsidies to ensure cheap fuel for their people. Saudis, Iranians and
Iraqis pay 30 cents to 50 cents a gallon for gasoline. Venezuelans pay 7 cents,
and demand is projected to rise as much as 10 percent this year. Auto sales
have tripled in four years. These programs are popular even though experts say
they lead to wasteful energy use.
In
"To have a new car in my name is a dream
transformed into reality," Guerrero said. "I don't worry about the
climate or shortages of oil in the world. I just worry if gasoline prices go
up."
**********************************************************************************************************
9/ Seven South American countries forming their own development bank /
Iranian currency issues
(Le Monde, Mon 10 Dec)
http://www.lemonde.fr/web/article/0,1-0@2-3222,36-987726,0.html
Comment: The article is in French, so
no quotes here. Notes from an ODAC contact:
“I thought you might find this interesting - 7 South
American countries forming their own development bank. Given that
Also, did you see that
Interesting shifts going on in the world.”
**********************************************************************************************************
10/ Transport and post-Peak Oil
(ODAC, Mon 03 Dec)
http://www.odac-info.org/
Bulletin Board
Comment: This was added to the ODAC
Bulletin Board last week.
Article: As Peak
Oil approaches, we see modern industrial countries pursuing transport
developments that just do not make sense, major new roads and airports spring
to mind. Even for those (in the
"Some initiatives have been taking place in the private
sector, aimed at phasing out dependence on fossil fuels in urban public
transport. Official bodies such as the 'Department for Transport' and
'Transport for
Perhaps way ahead of everyone else in thinking about Peak Oil and transport is Canadian Richard Gilbert. Along with his colleague Anthony Perl, they have written a book on the subject called Revolutions: Moving People and Freight Without Oil, due for release this month. The book is reviewed by the authors in a commentary for ASPO-USA, Preparing Transportation for Oil Depletion.
Update (07
December): An individualized transport system (Personal Rapid Transit or
"podcars") is being developed which potentially can be 100% solar
powered. A talk on this was recently given by Ron Swenson in
**********************************************************************************************************