ODAC News
Wednesday 22 Aug
The Oil Depletion Analysis Centre
Economics – Subprime Crisis
1/ Global financial problems continue
1a/ City
hit by biggest crisis for a decade
(The Telegraph, Sat 11 Aug)
1b/ Global
stock markets tumble on credit fears (The Telegraph, Fri 17 Aug)
1c/ Hedge
Funds Are Squeezed by Investors and Lenders
(The NY Times, Mon 20 Aug)
1d/ Business
comment: Sub-prime crisis is the edge of a financial hurricane
(The Telegraph, Mon 20 Aug)
2a/ Truck
Production in Russia Up 20%, to 158,000, in Seven Months [Car Production]
(FC Novosti, Fri 17 Aug)
2b/ Gazprom
Chooses First Supplier for Shtokman Project
(FC Novosti, Mon 20 Aug)
3a/ Revealed: cover-up plan on energy target
(The Guardian, Mon 13 Aug)
3b/ UK
gencos to invest $14 billion in low-carbon plant by
2012: AEP (Platts, Mon 13 Aug)
3c/ Go-ahead
for gas-fired power station (Financial Times, Mon 20 Aug)
3d/ No
New UK Nuclear Power Likely Before 2020 – Poyry
(
4a/ Turkmenistan
seeks other outlets besides Russia for gas exports
(Platts, Fri 17 Aug)
4b/ Kazakhstan
and China sign oil and gas pipelines agreement (Financial
Times, Mon 20 Aug)
Peak Oil -
5/ "Peak oil"
becomes burning issue (Swiss Info, Mon 20
Aug)
Coal Imports -
6/ Asia's thermal coal
supply squeeze to worsen in '08 (Reuters, Fri 17 Aug)
Big Oil – R&D Spending
7/ COMPANIES
INTERNATIONAL: Oil groups put faith in R&D as states lock up
(Financial Times, Tue 21 Aug)
8/ Tehran advised not to
export gas (The International News [
Russian Oil Production
9a/ For
Russia, An End To Growth is In Sight
(ASPO-USA, Wed 15 Aug)
9b/ Russia
Oil Report (Whiskey and Gunpowder, May/June 2007 ?)
10/ Exit
Iran's oil minister, and a pipeline too
(Asia Times, Fri 17 Aug)
**********************************************************************************************************
1/ Global financial problems continue
Comment: In last Sunday’s (12th
Aug) ODAC News, the first and main item was about the crisis that has hit the
global financial markets. It has been several months, arguably years, coming,
but Thursday 9th Aug stood out because the European Central Bank
pumped 95 billion Euros into the European financial institutions, apparently to
prevent several of them from sinking. Some commentators in the press are
alluding to the crash of ’29. There are a lot of similarities. In any case,
it looks like we will not know how bad the knock-on effects of the subprime
scam will be until well into next year, due to the complexities of the subprime
derivatives involved. Therefore, any comments or headlines to the effect that
the worst is over, all is well, are at the very least premature, probably with
the aim of boosting confidence.
What has the current financial crisis got to do with
Peak Oil / Gas? Many things. The stock markets rely on confidence, amongst
other things. A lack of confidence is what has to a large extent made the
current crisis worse than it might otherwise have been, due to the so-called
credit squeeze. Many Peak Oil observers expect investor confidence to plummet
once it is realised Peak Oil really is here, with economic consequences similar
to the current problems. It is also possible that the global economy will now
go into recession, oil demand and therefore oil prices will fall, and Peak Oil
will be pushed even further off the political agenda, until the next big jump
in oil prices.
1a/ City hit by biggest crisis for a decade (The
Telegraph, Sat 11 Aug)
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2007/08/11/necon111.xml&DCMP=EMC-new_11082007
Comment: Intro from the Telegraph e-mail
bulletin: “
Article: On one of the worst days in
recent stock market history almost £56 billion was wiped off the value of
Experts predicted that the turbulence could have
knock-on effects for all British households, depressing the housing market,
potentially pushing unemployment higher and plunging pension funds into deficit.
They said the British economy's decade-long boom,
built for a large part on the success of the City, was facing its sternest
test, with many parts of the financial sector in a state of meltdown.
The dire predictions came as the benchmark FTSE 100 index
of leading shares plunged by 3.7 per cent, the biggest drop in more than four
years. In addition to massive losses in
Financial experts yesterday warned that the City was
officially facing a crisis, with shares having lost more than a 10th of their
value since June.
However, they added that the prospect of a full-blown
recession still seemed unlikely, since most other parts of the British economy
were still healthy.
... Prof Peter Spencer, an economic adviser to the
Ernst & Young Item Club, said
"We have become far too dependent on this kind of
growth," he said. "We are going to see a pretty big correction - but
it's a correction, not a crash.
"The age of big City bonuses is coming to an end.
... Prof Spencer said the crisis was in many senses
comparable to the Wall Street Crash.
He said: "When historians look back, I would
imagine they will compare this credit market slump with the events in
1929."
1b/ Global stock markets tumble on credit fears (The
Telegraph, Fri 17 Aug)
Comment: Intro from the Telegraph
e-mail bulletin: “The global credit crunch led to further sharp falls in the
share prices of mortgage lenders on both sides of the
Article: ... Emerging market stocks,
bonds, and currencies all began to suffer as hedge funds facing a deadline for
investor redemptions scrambled to exit vulnerable positions, with contagion now
spreading far beyond US sub-prime property debt.
This came as the US National Association of Realtors
reported that house sales dropped in all but a handful of states over the
April-June quarter, with falls of 41pc in
Merrill Lynch said Countrywide was increasingly
vulnerable to a "liquidity event" in the current grim mood. "We
fear the acceleration of margin calls and forced asset sales in the capital
markets could lead to more problems for it to finance its mortgage
operations," said the bank...
1c/ Hedge Funds Are Squeezed by Investors and Lenders
(The NY Times, Mon 20 Aug)
Comment: This article is one of many
that explains why it is so easy for Hedge Funds to go under at the moment. The
Hedge Fund borrows large amounts of money (“leveraging”) to buy so-called
financial instruments, the main culprit at the moment being investments
relating to subprime mortgages. As the value of the investment falls, the banks
demand an appropriate amount of lent money back (a margin call), enough to
cover the fall in value of the instrument. The banks may be demanding a lot of
money back, and the dodgy investment falling in value may be unsellable, as is currently the case with any investments
relating to the subprime market. The Hedge Fund then has to try and raise the
money for the margin call by selling other assets. Note that this is similar to
what happened on a much larger scale during the crash of ’29.
This same story is covered by last Thursday’s International
Herald Tribune, How
a hedge fund star lost it all. It makes clear that three of the big losers
who invested with Sowood were pension funds:
“Harvard's endowment lost $350 million, the
Article: As summer neared, investors
in Sowood Capital Management, a $3 billion hedge
fund, had little to complain about.
The fund was up 16 percent over the previous 12
months. Blue-chip management was in place, and any risk was well-hedged with a
comfortable cushion of financing in place, the fund said in a letter to
investors.
But a rocky June turned into a calamitous July, and by
the end of the month, Sowood was on the brink of
collapse. As the credit market tightened, Sowood had
to sell stocks to meet margin calls from skittish banks and add hundreds of
millions in cash reserves.
Sowood’s
manager, Jeffrey Larson, sold the rest of the portfolio seemingly overnight —
at a fraction of its initial value — and embarked on what he would later
describe as a “deeply painful” process of returning the remaining money to
investors and shutting the funds.
As problems that began in subprime mortgage lending
have expanded into the broader markets, hedge funds like Sowood
have come face to face with the ghost of past financial crises: the one-two
liquidity punch from banks and investors.
On the one side, Wall Street banks and brokerage
firms, as they did with Sowood, have stepped up their
demands for more cash and collateral as they restrict the money they are
willing to lend.
On the other, jittery investors seem ready to flee at
any sign of trouble, as they did from the Bear Stearns Asset-Backed Securities
Fund. The fund had a solid track record, no leverage and little exposure to
subprime mortgages, but after it reported losses in July, investors demanded
their money and Bear Stearns was forced to suspend redemptions…
1d/ Business comment: Sub-prime crisis is the edge of a financial hurricane
(The Telegraph, Mon 20 Aug)
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/money/main.jhtml?xml=/money/2007/08/20/ccom120.xml&DCMP=EMC-mcn_20082007
Comment: From the article:
“Greenspan did manage to avoid, or at least to postpone, a re-run of the early
1930s by slashing interest rates in 2001 when the US economy threatened to fall
off the edge of a cliff. That is a performance his successor is going to have
to repeat now that the
Article: It is hard to overstate the
seriousness of the global financial crisis. Yet the world's central monetary
authorities - the central banks - have been culpably slow to recognise how
dangerous things have become.
Initially, the crisis emerged from the
As long as
But
The root cause of a credit bubble is not financial
market greed (though that has certainly been present) but an inappropriate
level of real interest rates that sends misleading signals about the
feasibility of continuing to consume today while ignoring tomorrow. In the
The late-1990s result was, as in the late 1920s, a
frenetic stock market boom, massive business over-investment financed by
credit, not by postponed consumption (saving), and an inevitable collapse.
Greenspan did manage to avoid, or at least to postpone, a re-run of the early
1930s by slashing interest rates in 2001 when the
**********************************************************************************************************
2a/ Truck Production in
http://www.fcinfo.ru/themes/basic/materials-rfcm-index.asp?folder=3352
Comment: Many articles over the last 6
months have suggested car production in Russia increasing at 20-50% / annum,
which may be the case for individual companies. The overall growth is much
lower, nearer 10%.
Article: Car production in
2b/ Gazprom Chooses First Supplier for Shtokman Project
(FC Novosti, Mon 20 Aug)
http://www.fcinfo.ru/themes/basic/materials-rfcm-index.asp?folder=3192
Article: Russian energy giant Gazprom
has chosen the first supplier for the development of the Shtokman gas
condensate field in the
It is the
**********************************************************************************************************
3a/ Revealed: cover-up plan on energy target [
http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2007/aug/13/renewableenergy.energy
Comment: Summary: <<It
[the report] says the
Article: Government officials have
secretly briefed ministers that
In contrast to the government's claims to be leading
the world on climate change, officials within the former Department of Trade
and Industry have admitted that under current policies Britain would miss the EU's 2020 target of 20% energy from renewables by a long
way. And their suggestion that "statistical interpretations of the
target" be used rather than new ways to reach it has infuriated
environmentalists.
An internal briefing paper for ministers, a copy of
which has been obtained by the Guardian, reveals that officials at the
department, now the Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform,
think the best the UK could hope for is 9% of energy from renewable sources
such as wind, solar or hydro by 2020.
It says the
Under current policies renewables would account for
only 5% of
EU leaders agreed the 20% target for the bloc in spring.
The European Commission is working out how to reach this.
… The paper also reveals that carbon capture and
underground storage of CO2 emissions from new coal-fired power stations is
projected to make little contribution before 2020…
3b/
Comment: The article refers to
"invest[ing] more than GBP7 billion in 15 GW of
low carbon plant over the next five years", of which "8 GW of clean
coal projects". However, as item 3a points out, clean coal is unlikely to
be with us before 2020, if then. One could argue that, until then, it is hardly
low-carbon. As mentioned before, the
Article:
A further 8 GW of clean coal projects and "a
considerable amount of renewable energy generation is under
consideration," said AEP, whose members account for more than 90% of
But AEP estimates its members will have to spend
"at least GBP20 billion by 2020 to fill the gap left by closing nuclear
and coal-fired power stations," said its chief executive, David Porter.
Most of this investment would be in gas-fired plant, renewables and clean coal,
he said, as well as nuclear if the outcome of the
Porter called for a clear, long-term stable regulatory
regime for reducing CO2 emissions, and in particular more information about
post-2012 emission allowances in the EU emissions trading scheme, to ensure the
investment needed is made.
3c/ Go-ahead for gas-fired power station
(Financial Times, Mon 20 Aug)
Comment: Login required for full
article. The FT suggests this might be the beginning of another ‘dash for gas’
in the
Department for Business,
Article: A new gas-fired power station
in south
Carron
Energy, an independent generator and electricity supplier, has won approval
from the Department for Business,
3d/ No New
http://www.planetark.com/dailynewsstory.cfm/newsid/43823/story.htm
Comment: As mentioned already, when
the
Article: No nuclear power plants are
likely to be built in Britain before 2020, if they are built at all, which will
be too late to fill the country's looming power generation gap, according to a
report published on Monday.
The British government wants the private sector to
build new nuclear power plants to replace the country's ageing reactors and
plug a generation shortfall left by the closure of coal-fired power plants
under European environment laws.
But the report by Poyry
Energy Consulting says the commercial case for building new nuclear plants is
shaky and that none will be built without a higher long-term carbon price than
that set by the current European Union Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS).
"Despite the rhetoric, it is difficult to see
much new nuclear capacity coming into the market before 2020," Poyry director Andrew Nind said.
... Environmental regulations could force many of
Britain's coal fired power plants to close over the next decade, while all but
one of its nuclear power plants are expected to shut by 2020, leaving a gaping
hole that new nuclear cannot fill in time.
The government wants atomic energy to play a part in
A spokeswoman for the department responsible for
energy said on Monday the government was already trying to work out how the
country will cope if no nuclear power plants are built.
The government admitted last week that
**********************************************************************************************************
4a/
http://www.platts.com/podcasts/news/index.xml
Comment: Podcast (4m 43 s) from
Platts, discussing natural gas exports from Turkmenistan and Azerbaijan,
various gas supply pipelines to Europe including the Nabucco pipeline, and the
fact, usually overlooked by most commentators, that Russia needs more Central
Asian natural gas just to maintain its indigenous consumption/exports to
Europe, let alone increase them.
4b/
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/fdb5e094-4eb4-11dc-85e7-0000779fd2ac.html
Article:
"The Caspian will be linked to western
China," Nursultan Nazarbayev,
the president of Kazakhstan, said after a meeting with Hu
Jintao, the Chinese leader, in Astana, the Kazakh
capital, on Saturday.
The agreement marks a setback for the European Union
and the
The projects may also be regarded grudgingly by
Last year,
That pipeline will now be connected with another CNPC
field and pipeline in western
CNPC plans to expand its presence in
Julia Nanay, a senior
director at PFC Energy, said: "The oil pipeline to
Mr Nazarbayev said the
pipeline from
The pipeline, designed to carry up to 30bn cubic
metres a year of gas, will provide
However,
*The Chinese Exim Bank has
signed an agreement to award a $292.8m credit to Kazakhstan Aluminum
Smelter, part of the Eurasian Natural Resources Corporation, the Kazakh group,
to build a smelter in
**********************************************************************************************************
5/ "Peak oil" becomes burning issue
(Swiss Info, Mon 20 Aug)
Comment: From the ‘About’ page of
Swiss Info: “swissinfo/Swiss Radio International
(SRI) is an enterprise of the Swiss Broadcasting Corporation (SBC). Its role is
to inform Swiss living abroad about events in their homeland and to raise
awareness of
Article: Swiss scientists say
politicians and the public should have a greater awareness of "peak
oil" – the moment when the world's maximum crude oil output is reached.
Researchers at
"The question is not for how long we will have
crude oil reserves, but for how long output can grow," warned Daniele Ganser, a historian and
peace researcher at
No one can agree on when exactly the moment of
"peak oil" will be – some experts say 2010, others say 2020 or 2030 –
but it is a serious problem as crude oil output has grown for decades and
positively boomed with the industrialisation of the emerging nations.
An end to the spiral is not in sight and once the
global peak is reached, a further increase is simply not possible.
"Conflict over crude oil will increase in
proportion with its scarcity – the global economy is facing a recession,"
said Ganser.
"We are running to the oil limit without
thinking. It's as if we planned to climb the
Low visibility
Ganser
says the issue of peak oil is barely a topic in public debate because it is not
immediately visible.
"If oil supplies run low, they are
imported," he said. "That also goes for the oil-producing countries
that have already reached the peak."
A switch to gas or coal is not a solution, according
to Ganser. "These energy sources are also finite
and will one day reach their maximum output. It would therefore be wrong for
Ganser
points out that as early as 1978
"Resource conflicts"
Wolfgang Sachs, a sociologist at the Wuppertal Institute for Climate, Environment and Energy, is
also calling for a reduction in energy consumption.
"It is a stroke of luck that climate chaos and
the issue of peak oil have hit the global agenda at virtually the same
time," he says, explaining that peak oil and the climbing price of oil
have a direct effect on every business's finances.
"That means that people in the northern
countries, which won't be affected by the climate chaos until later, will take
the problem seriously."
Sachs says an economic development that is based on
fossil fuels as a source of energy is a "large security risk".
"The fact that oil is finite is a destabilising
factor," he said. "Before we reach the ecological limits of what we
can bear, we will reach the social ones."
He describes ethnic and social conflicts such as those
in
Like Ganser, Sachs sees a
way out of the crisis in renewable energies, new and efficient technologies and
in a drastic reduction of energy consumption.
"Cars with a top speed of 100km/h would be
absolutely adequate," he said.
**********************************************************************************************************
6/
http://in.reuters.com/article/businessNews/idINIndia-29022120070817
Article: Asia's thermal coal supply
squeeze, which has driven spot prices to record highs of over $72 a tonne, is
set to worsen next year as Indonesia and Australia struggle to meet feverish
demand growth in China and India.
Tight supply could push spot prices to average about
$75 a tonne in the first quarter of 2008, traders and producers said, and
long-term contract prices between Australian producers and Japanese utilities
by as much as 10 percent.
"The market is going to be very, very tight next
year. It will be worse than this year," Peter Ball, vice president for
marketing at
"Apart from
Coal consumption is expected to increase rapidly in
... Many analysts and officials have said the Chinese
coal market was likely to reach a balance this year and would become a net
importer next year. It was a net importer in the first half of this year, but
restored its net exporting status in July.
Some producers estimated that
Industry sources said high international prices have
prompted Chinese utilities in the southern coast to increasingly seek
sub-bituminous coal, which has lower heating value, to fuel their power plants
-- a move that would jeopardise South Korea's and India's coal supplies.
The scramble for alternative suppliers would mean
demand for South African, Russian and even Canadian coal shipments, which have
trickled into
... Underpinned by growing Asia-Pacific demand, coal
prices are likely to stay at robust levels in the next five years,
"The situation of undersupply, or supply
tightness, will likely remain for quite a few years because there are very few
large-scale coal mines coming online," said Alan Copeland, a commodity
analyst at the Australian Bureau for Agriculture and Resource Economics.
"And nearly every country in
**********************************************************************************************************
7/ COMPANIES INTERNATIONAL: Oil groups put faith in R&D as states lock
up
(Financial Times, Tue 21 Aug)
http://search.ft.com/nonFtArticle?id=070821000659
Comment: The title of the article is
bit of a misnomer. The gist of the article is that Big Oil puts very little
money into R&D, especially compared to other sectors.
Article: The world's international oil
companies are increasing investments in technology to ensure their survival in
an industry now dominated by their state-owned rivals.
... A survey by the Financial Times of the larger oil
companies shows that R&D spending by many has jumped sharply recently.
Royal Dutch Shell has raised its technology R&D
budget 50 per cent over the past three years to $1.2bn in 2006. Chevron's
R&D has more than doubled over the past five years from $221m in 2002 to
$468m last year. ConocoPhillips has budgeted $400m for this year, which is up
about 50 per cent from what it historically spends.
The rise in R&D spending at ExxonMobil, the
world's biggest international oil company, is less dramatic, up from $631m in
2002 to $733m last year. Exxon said this reflected the "priority" it
had always given R&D.
"It is particularly through technology that the
international oil companies can differentiate themselves,'' said Jan van der Eijk, Shell's chief
technology officer.
Yet analysts consider recent commitments small when
compared with other industries. Amy Myers Jaffe, energy expert at
"I couldn't put Microsoft, GM or Merck on the same
slide with ExxonMobil, or ExxonMobil would have been too small.'' Microsoft
spent $7.1bn, or almost 14 per cent of its revenues, on R&D in the year to
the end of June, while General Motors spent some $6.6bn or 3.2 per cent of
revenues, in 2006. Exxon, in contrast, spent just 0.2 per cent of its 2006
revenues on R&D.
Oil companies insist they commit far more to R&D
than the numbers reflect as it is spread throughout the business. It can take a
decade to test and implement new technology.
"We had to ask ourselves what was the right level
of sustained investment through the cycles,'' said Ryan Lance, ConocoPhillips'
senior vice-president for technology. "Seven years ago, the price of oil
was $12 a barrel; you have to look at it in that context.''
**********************************************************************************************************
8/
http://www.thenews.com.pk/top_story_detail.asp?Id=9691
Comment: Several warnings have come
out over the last year suggesting that
For
Large domestic grid at prices of 1 cent/cubic
meter.
Massive gas injection requirements of some 10
billion cf/d.
Massive gas-based petrochemical projects.
CNG projects to provide a major volume of gasoline
supplies as early as end of this decade.
Major political opposition to gas exports.
Article: An influential research
centre of Iranian parliament has sounded a downbeat note on the future of
The warning was supported by
But
**********************************************************************************************************
9a/ For
http://www.aspo-usa.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=194&Itemid=91
Comment:
Article:
... It is uncertain whether
9b/
http://www.whiskeyandgunpowder.com/ppc/RussianOilReport2.html
Comment: This very interesting and
insightful overview of Russian oil companies explains some of the internal
geopolitics/politics going on in
Article: The Russian government has
steadily extended its reach over the country's energy industry over the past
four years, building its state companies into major global players. Originally,
the logic for the expansion was nationalist and political. Russian power
players were incensed that oligarchs (or even worse, foreigners) were able to
profit from private ownership of the country's oil wealth -- and by
consolidating, the Kremlin gained access to a powerful tool for influencing the
behavior of the European states downstream.
But now there is a new logic in the nationalization
process: political competition. Within Russian President Vladimir Putin's inner circle there are two power centers. The first, comprising First Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev and Deputy Chief
of Staff Vladislav Surkov,
is the power behind Gazprom, the Russian state natural gas mammoth. The second,
comprising Sergei Ivanov
and Igor Sechin -- who share Medvedev
and Surkov's titles, respectively -- controls
Rosneft, Russia's major state oil firm.
The Gazprom and Rosneft teams are more than simply two
adversarial state companies. They are the two factions struggling to succeed
Putin as
[The article then goes on to review the chances of
various Russian oil companies chances of surviving assimilation.]
**********************************************************************************************************
10/ Exit
http://www.atimes.com/atimes/South_Asia/IH17Df01.html
Comment: An update on the outlook for
Indian natural gas supplies. Amongst other things, the journalist suggests that
prospects for imports from
Article:
The prospects for the US$7.5 billion
Iran-India-Pakistan (IPI) gas pipeline took a big hit with the dramatic firing
of