ODAC News
Sunday 29 April
The Oil Depletion Analysis Centre
1/ Pickens: $80 a barrel this year
(CNN Money [Reuters], Tue 24 Apr)
2a/ Spain
hit by property crash fears (BBC News,
Wed 25 Apr)
2b/ As
Spain falters, is the world's property boom coming to an end?
(The Independent, Thu 26 Apr)
2c/ Rate
rises could spark housing crash, says Nationwide
(The Independent, Fri 27 Apr)
3/ Alberta's oil boom is
already over (Toronto Star, Wed 25 Apr)
4a/ Non-OPEC
oil output seen peaking by 2015 –WoodMac
(Reuters UK, Tue 24 Apr)
4b/ Watch
Frank Harris in this pre-recorded video Access to Gas, the LNG Industry's Big
Challenge
(Wood Mackenzie, April 2007)
5/ Canada to Ban
Incandescent Light Bulbs by 2012 (
6a/ Moscow
backs Lukoil Iraq project
(Financial Times, Tue 24 Apr)
6b/ Another
100 billion barrels of oil found in Iraq?
(The Oil Drum, Sun 22 Apr)
7/ ANALYSIS - Mumbai
shortages highlight India power crunch (Reuters, Thu 26
Apr)
8/ Egypt weighs domestic
energy needs as export demands grow
(Financial Times, Tue 17 Apr)
9/ The
Honeymoon's Over for Bush and the Saudis
(The
10/ Norwegian
authorities fear steep crude decline
(Energy Bulletin, Mon 23 Apr)
**********************************************************************************************************
1/ Pickens: $80 a barrel this year
(CNN Money [Reuters], Tue 24 Apr)
Comment: This article does not contain
anything new. Just to point out that a lot of anti-Peak Oil articles over the
last few months (e.g. item 4a below) suggest that the anti-Peak Oil brigade
have somehow or other won the argument, i.e. plenty of oil, no problem. If CNN
Money is reporting T. Boone Pickens and giving him the limelight over Forbes
publisher and former
Article: Legendary oilman T. Boone
Pickens said Tuesday that global demand will outstrip supply in the fourth
quarter of this year, leading
Pickens would not predict how high beyond $80 oil
would go this year or in 2008 but said he was interested to see how long $80
oil will need to be sustained to lessen demand.
... Pickens, 79, began his career in the oil industry
in 1951 as a geologist and now heads BP Capital, a $4 billion hedge fund that
made $1 billion last year.
He picks $78 because oil hit a record high just over
that level last July when tensions began between Hezbollah and
"At some point prices will begin to kill
demand," said Pickens. "The only way to kill demand is price."
Reminded that $78 oil did not significantly lower
demand last summer, Pickens said that was because it did not stay there long
enough to test if that was a demand-killing price.
... "What's going to happen is the supply will
get very critical in the fourth quarter this year," Pickens said.
"Demand will be above supply and we'll see what happens."
Pickens said he has predicted $100-a-barrel oil and he
still thinks oil will reach that level, but he would not say when.
"We'll all see $100 in the future," Pickens
said. "Everybody says that. You're going to have to conserve at some
point. At what price will that conservation really kick in? Again, I don't
know."
... Forbes blamed money supply growth for near-record
high oil prices, citing policies by central banks, led by the U.S. Federal
Reserve.
The true price of oil is between $40-$45 per barrel,
Forbes said.
**********************************************************************************************************
2a/
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/6592203.stm
Comment: Several countries have
over-inflated property prices, driven high by low interest rates, individuals
too keen to go into debt, and banks only too willing to lend what in a
post-Peak world will look like ridiculous sums of money. The
“Coupled to this has been strong demand for housing
helped by the low interest rates that have also underpinned consumer spending
and allowed households to take on increasingly large amounts of debt.”
Article: Fears of a Spanish property
crash have increased, prompting a sell-off in real estate shares and fanning
concerns that thousands of Britons will lose money.
The sell-off was triggered by worries of rising bad
debts and speculation that one large company had been buying its own properties
to keep prices high.
Analysts warned that a crash could spread to the wider
Spanish economy
...
Coupled to this has been strong demand for housing
helped by the low interest rates that have also underpinned consumer spending
and allowed households to take on increasingly large amounts of debt.
However, in recent months cracks have started to
appear and mortgage demand has slowed as homeownership levels topped 85%.
On top of that, households now have some of the
highest debt levels in the eurozone, much of which is
based on variable lending rates leaving consumers open to sudden increases in
borrowing costs.
The worry is that should the suspected property bubble
burst, and some analysts estimate that house prices are overvalued by 30%, then
many other industries such as banking and retail would also suffer.
... Analysts warned that while the current fears of a
crash may be over amplified, the Spanish property boom that had provided strong
returns for the past eight years was probably over.
"The country is over-housed, households are
over-indebted and the construction industry continues to churn out
houses," said
According to
2b/ As
http://news.independent.co.uk/business/analysis_and_features/article2486662.ece
Article: Panic selling of Spanish real
estate stocks this week sent shudders through property markets worldwide. As
investors bet that
Mumbai -
Dubai - The sun always shines, salaries are tax-free
and the shopping and leisure facilities rival any other major global city -
welcome to Dubai, the largest of the United Arab Emirates, which has begun
weaning itself off oil and proving its credentials as a property paradise. An
estimated 15 to 25 per cent of the world's cranes are in
2c/ Rate rises could spark housing crash, says Nationwide
(The Independent, Fri 27 Apr)
http://news.independent.co.uk/business/news/article2489329.ece
Article:
Unveiling another punchy increase in house prices,
which pushed the annual rate of increase back up into double digits, Nationwide
said prices could fall sharply if borrowing costs were lifted above 6 per cent.
But it said the market remained on course for a soft landing if rates were
raised only once or twice more, to 5.5 or 5.75 per cent, as expected.
"In our view, the talk of rates climbing to 6 per
cent and beyond is overblown and if implemented in the current climate could be
damaging to housing market stability," said Fionnuala
Earley, Nationwide's chief
economist.
"With the market already showing signs of
cooling, too sharp a rate hike could undermine market confidence and dry up
demand swiftly. But on top of this, they could also lead to widespread payment
difficulties which, in an illiquid market, could precipitate price falls."
Ms Earley said some
month-on-month price falls next year could not be ruled out in any case, but
"would not be a disaster". Indeed, prices in the north of
Rates would have to rise by another 2 percentage
points before affordability for buyers became as stretched as it was before the
property crash of the early 1990s, the building society said...
**********************************************************************************************************
3/
http://www.thestar.com/opinion/article/206701
Comment: The title of the article
refers to a drop in oil and gas royalties and conventional oil production, not to
the total volume of oil being produced.
“Even when [oil sands] production triples to 3 million
barrels a day in 2020” – this is the first time I have seen Canadian mainstream
media print a realistic forecast for oil sands production in 2020. Usually it
is at least 3Mb/d by 2015. 3Mb/d by 2020 is probably the upper limit.
Article: In the midst of this
energy-driven boom, it's hard to imagine that the gravy train is already
slowing down.
But the truth is the provincial government faces a 33
per cent drop in oil and gas royalties over the next three years, and Albertans
should take a close look at the reasons behind it.
First, the supplies of easy-to-get conventional oil
and gas have declined to the point that almost 90 per cent of wells are
permanently paying lower royalty rates, many as low as 5 per cent.
The highest royalty rate is about 30 per cent, but
with so many wells now at the "low productivity rate," the average
royalty from conventional oil and gas is down to 20 per cent.
Natural gas, the biggest money spinner for years,
which pumped $8.3 billion into the treasury in 2005-06, will bring in only
about half that amount, $4.6 billion, by 2009-10.
Conventional oil royalties will also come down.
They'll bring in $1 billion this year, one-third less than two years ago, and
drop to just $815 million in 2009-10.
Without the oil sands,
It's tempting to ask, why worry? Oil-sands production
is expected to last 40 to 50 years. But the oil sands will never yield the rich
flow of petrodollars pumped into the treasury by conventional oil and gas.
Despite the fact that production is rising dramatically,
oil-sands royalties will go down, from a high of $2.3 billion last year to $1.1
billion in 2009-10.
Even when production triples to 3 million barrels a
day in 2020, royalties will be stuck at $1.1 billion, the same level as
2004-05, according to one report…
**********************************************************************************************************
4a/ Non-OPEC oil output seen peaking by 2015 –WoodMac
(Reuters UK, Tue 24 Apr)
http://uk.reuters.com/article/oilRpt/idUKSP4119220070424
Comment: Wood Mackenzie have in the
past produced a lot of good oil and gas reports. See item 4b for example. It is
therefore baffling that they have global oil production growing to 2025, at
least. Is it acceptable to warn of global shortages of natural gas, but not
oil? Perhaps. At a conference two weeks ago in Edinburgh (see Energy
for Scotland : is there a consensus), William C.
Ramsay, Deputy Executive Director of the International Energy Agency, said the
IEA thought Peak Oil would not happen for something like 20-30 years (I cannot
remember his exact words), but that they were now getting seriously concerned
about future natural gas supplies, without going into any detail.
Some of the figures in this article are just
unbelievable:
-
non-OPEC output will force the
cartel to hold back some 8 million bpd of capacity by early next decade
-
… which should revive oil to around
$60 by 2025
-
Broughton estimated that
This reads a bit like a CERA statement.
Note that in its latest Medium Term Oil Market Report (Feb 2007), and in
various recent speeches, the IEA has/is warning that it expects global spare
capacity to remain very tight until at least 2011, and goes into a lot of
detail in the MT OMR why. In fact, the IEA has OPEC spare capacity at 4-6 Mb/d
(not so different from WoodMac’s 8 Mb/d) by 2011. But
it hints that most of this may not be sellable if it is of the wrong quality,
and therefore real spare capacity may be say 2 Mb/d, or less.
The tone of the article seems to be a bit anti-Peak
Oil: “Countering doomsday 'peak oil' theorists”, and “The study may put to rest
immediate concerns over the oil industry's ability to cope with rapid demand
growth”. Put to rest?
Article: Oil production outside the
OPEC cartel will keep rising until about 2015, while global output will
continue to expand through 2025 at least, a top analyst at consultancy Wood
Mackenzie said on Tuesday.
Countering doomsday "peak oil" theorists who
believe global oil production may be reaching its limits, Wood Mackenzie said
research based on its database of field-by-field global data showed supplies
should keep expanding for at least 20 years.
It expects global oil production outside the
Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries to rise to about 52 million
barrels per day (bpd) by 2015 from 47 million bpd now, based mostly on existing
fields and imminent developments, Kate Broughton, head of oils research at Wood
Mackenzie, told Reuters.
That is an annual average growth rate of around 1.25
percent, while OPEC capacity will rise even more quickly.
The study may put to rest immediate concerns over the
oil industry's ability to cope with rapid demand growth in big consumers such
as the
Against oil demand estimated to rise an average annual
1.8 percent up to 2015, non-OPEC output will force the cartel to hold back some
8 million bpd of capacity by early next decade, a factor that could send price
down to $45, she said.
"Around that point (spare capacity) begins to
tail off again," she added, which should revive oil to around $60 by 2025,
in a repeat of the capacity crunch that caused a spike in 2004. It expects oil
demand to grow an average 1.1 percent a year from 2015 to 2025.
Broughton estimated that
By 2025, Wood Mackenzie expects non-OPEC production to
fall back to 47.2 million bpd, taking into account likely future discoveries
and improved recovery at existing fields.
"It's a gradual decline," Broughton said.
Wood Mackenzie also estimated that fuel produced from
biofuels, gas-to-liquids, coal-to-liquids and shale oil would account for about
7 percent of capacity by 2025.
4b/ Watch Frank Harris in this pre-recorded video Access to Gas, the LNG
Industry's Big Challenge (Wood
Mackenzie, April 2007)
http://www.woodmacresearch.com/cgi-bin/wmprod/portal/energy/energyPortal.jsp
Comment: Wood Mackenzie 13.5 minute
video. The video warns of LNG shortages between now and 2010. Beyond 2011, shortages
may get worse. Frank Harris also states that the International Oil Companies
are exploring for gas more now because it is getting harder and harder to find
decent sized oil fields! A very good overview of why LNG supplies are tight,
about to get tighter.
Article: Watch Frank Harris, Head of
Global LNG, in this pre-recording of his address given at LNG 15 April 24th.
The paper entitled Access to Gas - The LNG Industry's Big Challenge was
co-authored with Gavin Law, Head of Gas & Power Consulting and presented
during the session - Commercialisation and Globalisation - Challenges and
Opportunities of LNG's Emerging Global Reach.
With strong demand and abundant shipping and
regasification capacity, the weak link in the LNG value chain increasingly
looks like LNG supply – will there be enough supply available to meet demand?
In the short-to medium term, the big concern is
whether the next wave of LNG plants can be developed on schedule, while in the
longer-term, the big worry is whether the industry can access sufficient gas
reserves to feed the LNG plants needed to meet forecast demand.
Therefore, in our opinion, the industry’s obsession
with supply is justified. LNG supply is a big issue in the short, medium and
long-term and we expect problems will LNG supply to constrain the growth of the
industry.
**********************************************************************************************************
5/
http://www.planetark.com/dailynewsstory.cfm/newsid/41556/story.htm
Article:
"Making the switch to more efficient lighting is
one of the easiest and most effective things we can do to reduce energy use and
harmful emissions," Lunn told a news conference.
If households installed compact fluorescent bulbs --
which use about 75 percent less electricity than old-style bulbs -- they could
save C$50 (US$44) a year, he said.
"By banning inefficient lighting, we can reduce
our greenhouse gas emissions by more than 6 million tonnes per year," Lunn said.
The ban will not apply to uses where incandescent
bulbs are still the only practical alternative.
The Canadian
**********************************************************************************************************
6a/
Comment: Russian oil company LUKoil has been very busy the last two years in
Article: The Russian government is
throwing its full support behind Lukoil’s ambition to
become the first big international energy group to develop a major Iraqi oil
field following the 2003
Vagit Alekperov, Lukoil’s chief
executive, said in an interview on Tuesday: “The Russian government supports
us, the foreign ministry supports us, the president of the federation supports
us. They support the idea of putting those Iraqi fields [into production] as
soon as possible. In all these areas we have the support of the Russian government.”
He added that Lukoil would
be able to develop the
West Qurna is believed to
hold as many as 11bn-15bn barrels of recoverable oil reserves and has a
potential to produce as many as 1m barrels a day, making it one of the world’s
biggest fields.
International energy companies such as ExxonMobil,
Royal Dutch Shell and BP have been waiting for the security situation in
But at least one
… In the past two years Lukoil
has spent $20m to train 1000-2000 Iraqi oil field engineers in Russian fields,
put another 100 through Russian universities and provide equipment for
6b/ Another 100 billion barrels of oil found in
http://europe.theoildrum.com/node/2480#more
Comment: Last week (18th
April) the Financial Times announced a report by IHS that there were,
maybe, over 200B barrels of oil in
Article: I actually went to the website
of IHS and found the underlying press
release. It's transparently an attempt to sell their maps to oil producers
seeking new oil fields. While IHS is a respected player in the industry, and is
known to have one of the most extensive proprietary databases on world oil
fields, it is a lot harder to gauge the reliability of this new publication.
And of course, as the FT article above notes (those innocuous *if* I
bolded), and as I have pointed out before in my comments on the new Iraqi oil
law (see this story here on TOD: New
Iraqi oil law: some facts on PSAs), there is the
small issue of the lack of security and, more importantly, the lack of
legitimacy of the current government, which makes it certain that
- no money will be invested (as opposed to "deals of the century"
mooted, announced or even signed) as long as the civil war rages, i.e. for a
bit longer than American forces will be in the country;
- any contract signed today will be re-negotiated in full when a new regime
finally emerges.
Did Bush and Cheney genuinely expect a "cakewalk"? Are they just
playing a cynical game to deny oil to the market (in the short term) and to
preserve the biggest untapped reserves on the planet (in the long term)? Did
they simply expect to get US companies to replace the French and the Russians
that were sniffing around
**********************************************************************************************************
7/ ANALYSIS - Mumbai shortages highlight
Comment: There have been several
articles of late covering the natural gas shortages in
Article:
Mumbai, which aims to be a global financial centre,
might have cobbled enough supply together to keep its air-conditioning and fans
on for now and avoid the hours of blackouts suffered daily by its outlying
areas, as well as other towns and cities.
But to highlight the problem's urgency, power supplier
Tata Power Co. Ltd has urged Mumbai citizens to cut
down air-conditioning use, change light bulbs and put computers on sleep mode
to conserve energy.
"This is a wake up call for
"It shows
India, which has a population of 1.1 billion and
rising, has suffered power shortages for years, especially in the peak summer
months when temperatures in some parts of the country can reach more than 45
degrees celsius.
But an economy which has grown at about 9 percent for
two years and an expanding middle class are hotting
up demand for electrical goods as well as malls, air-conditioned homes and
offices, which are springing up across the country.
Even
In Kolkata, two million
customers live without power for up to eight hours a day, worse than two to
three hours of previous years. Villages often spend half the day cut off as
their power share gets diverted to factories and offices.
"This in an annual problem, but this year the
problem has been even more acute," said Harry Dhaul,
of the Independent Power Producers Association of India.
... But new projects may not be able to cope with
soaring demand, growing at 8-9 percent a year. The government plans to add more
than 78,500 megawatts of power generation capacity by 2012 on top of
India's total installed capacity is more than 128,000
MW, but only three-quarters of that is available at any given time, with per
capita consumption at 615 kilowatts per hour, a quarter of the global average.
... "In the next 25 years, even if we are able to
raise our installed capacity by five to six times, the shortage situation would
continue," said R.V. Shahi, a former federal
power official.
**********************************************************************************************************
8/
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/abbfeb72-ec80-11db-a12e-000b5df10621.html
Comment: Going in to some detail about
why
“All four [
Article: In the centre of Helwan town, a 20km drive south of one of
The Helwan plant was built
years ago but new, similar factories have sprung up as economic reforms attract
foreign investment.
The cement sector has been one of
... The growth of these industries has coincided with
rising domestic demand for gas, putting a huge burden on the treasury as energy
subsidies have swelled from E£1.2bn ($220m, €162.8m, £110.8m) in 1999 to
E£42bn, according to figures on a government website.
... In recent weeks - after a temporary moratorium -
the trade ministry has approved licences to 25 new cement factories and three
steel companies. About six companies, including Australian, Chinese and
Canadian concerns, are also seeking to set up aluminium smelters - which are
even more energy intensive - in the country.
... Colin Lothian, an analyst at Wood Mackenzie, says
the
All four could eventually face gas shortages,
according to Wood Mackenzie, as they seek to sustain development plans.
In the late 1990s Oman, believing it had ample gas
resources, encouraged the establishment of fertiliser plants and an aluminium
smelter, but today faces a supply-demand gap, Mr Lothian says, as development
of new gas supplies failed to live up to expectations.
In
**********************************************************************************************************
9/ The Honeymoon's Over for Bush and the Saudis
(The
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/04/27/AR2007042702054_pf.html
Article: What has happened to the love
affair between
So the White House was mightily perplexed when it was
informed that the king's schedule didn't allow for a spring visit to
What was going on? Simply put, the Bush administration
had been listening to the wrong Saudi. Keen for any signs of hope in the region
as
... If Bush wants to rekindle the U.S.-Saudi love
affair, he needs to deal with the Saudi leader we have, not the one we'd like.
That needn't mean total despair on the Arab-Israeli
front. Peace with
His opening price is Bush's accommodation of Hamas and
**********************************************************************************************************
10/ Norwegian authorities fear steep crude decline
(Energy Bulletin, Mon 23 Apr)
http://www.energybulletin.net/29073.html
Article: This is a direct quotation by
Norwegian Oil Director Mr. Gunnar Berge from the
Foreword to Facts - The Norwegian Petroleum Sector - 2007 (220-page PDF)
published by the Norwegian Ministry of Petroleum and Energy on Friday, April
w0:
Forecasts show that gas production is rising while oil
production is declining. The number of exploration wells increased
significantly in 2006 compared with the previous year, but only six new
discoveries were made. These were made in four wellbores.
This is figures for reflection [stet]. If we are to achieve the development
that we want, with only a slow and gradual decline, serious efforts must be
made in several areas.
(page 8)
What is the Norwegian Oil Director actually predicting
here?
He is establishing "a slow and gradual
decline" as a best case scenario for
Contrary to natural gas, Norwegian crude production
has actually been in decline since 2001, but far from acknowledging Hubbert's
Peak, the tune from the authorities has up till now been something like
"maybe we will be on the increase again next year, due to our investments
and many nice enhanced oil recovery (EOR) techniques." Now Hubbert's Peak
is finally official in
While the crude production forecast for 2007 is about
130 million standard cubic metres, the Norwegian crude reserves now officially
stands at about 1 billion, reduced by nearly 15 percent only last year. Very
little new oil will be coming on stream during the next few years due to minor
discoveries. Under such circumstances, with an R/P* of 7-8 years, who can
really believe in "a slow and gradual decline" ?
**********************************************************************************************************